another term, as the thing to be proved; and therefore is no argument at all, but only begging
the question.
Or if the point I thus take for granted, and make use of as an argument, be neither the
general point in controversy, nor yet the thing nextly to be proved under a particular argu-
ment; yet if it be some known controverted point between the parties, it is begging the
question, or equivalent to it: for it is begging a thing known to be in question in the dispute,
and using it as if it were a thing allowed.
I would now consider the instances, wherein Mr. W. asserts or suggests that I have
begged the question.
In p. 30. d. e. and 31. a. b. he represents the force of my reasoning as built on a suppos-
ition, that there is no unsanctified man, but what knows he has no desire of salvation by
Christ, no design to fulfil the covenant of grace, but designs to live in stealing, lying, adul-
tery,—or some other known sin: and then says, “Is it not manifest, that such sort of reasoning
is a mere quibbling with words, and begging the question?” And so insinuates, that I have
thus begged the question. Whereas, I nowhere say or suppose this which he speaks of, nor
any thing like it. But on the contrary, often say, what supposes an unsanctified man may
516
think he is truly godly, and that he has truly upright and gracious designs and desires.—Nor
does any argument of mine depend on any such supposition. Nay, under the argument he
speaks of, I expressly suppose the contrary, viz. That unsanctified men who visibly enter
into covenant, may be deceived.
In p. 38. a. Mr. W. makes a certain representation of my arguing from Isaiah lvi. and
then says upon it, “It is no arguing, but only begging the question.” But as has been already
shown, that which he represents as my argument from that scripture, has no relation to my
argument.
In p. 59. in opposition to my arguing from the Epistles, that the apostles treated those
members of churches which they wrote to, as those who had been received on a positive
judgment, i.e. (as I explain myself,) a proper and affirmative opinion, that they were real
saints; Mr. W. argues, that the apostles could make no such judgment of them, without
either personal converse, or revelation; unless it be supposed to be founded on a presumption,
that ministers who baptized them, would not have done it, unless they had themselves made
such a positive judgment concerning their state: and then adds these words, This may do
for this scheme, but only it is a begging the question. Whereas, it is a point that never has
been in question in this controversy, as ever I knew, whether some ministers or churches
might reasonably and affirmatively suppose, the members of other churches they are united
with, were admitted on evidence of proper qualifications, (whatever they be, whether common
or saving,) trusting to the faithfulness of other ministers and churches. Besides, this can be
no point in question between me and Mr. W. unless it be a point in question between him
and himself. For he holds, as well as I, that persons ought not to be received as visible
1988
SECTION VII. Begging the question.