it was great, if sometimes mistaken and overzealous, regard for what he deemed the public
welfare, and on quite a different plane from anything which we express as cruelty. Though
with the growing conservatism of a man who finds his purposes of mercy continually per-
verted and his indulgences abused, he yet remained to the end of his life most merciful and
mild compared with those who went before and who followed.
This fact becomes more clear in seeing how he excelled in kindred virtues. The Patience
already mentioned, distinguished forbearance, and undoubted benevolence, or at least
generosity, are traits which group with mercy and have no fellowship with cruelty. And
these he had. He showed distinguished Forbearance, and that oftentimes, as in a disturbance
at Antioch, where he “applied with much forbearance the remedy of persuasion” (V. C. 3.
59). The outrageous conduct of those who, in the Arian disturbances, dared “even to insult
the statues of the emperor…had little power to excite his anger, but rather caused in him
sorrow of spirit” (V. C. 3. 4), “and he endured with patience men who were exasperated
against himself.” These words are by Eusebius, to be sure; but his conduct with Donatists,
Arians, Maximinianus, and Licinius, in individual and on the whole, show that in fact he
did habitually exercise great forbearance. To this was added much activity of positive
426
Kindness. On first accession he “visited with much considerate kindness all those provinces”
(V. C. p. 23). This kindness was shown throughout his reign, and brightly illustrated in his
treatment of the persecuted Christians from the beginning,—in his acts in Gaul, in his
famous toleration edict, in his letter to Maximin, and in his acts throughout. After his victory
over Maxentius came the edict that those wrongfully deprived of their estates should be
permitted to enjoy them again,…unjustly exiled were recalled and freed from imprisonment
(Euseb. V. C. 1. 41). After the victory over Licinius he recalled Christian exiles, ordered
restitution of property, released from labor in mines, from the solitude of islands, from toil
in public works, &c., those who had been oppressed in these ways (V. C. p. 70–71). There
is strong concensus of testimony to a very lovable habitual exercise of this trait in his
“readiness to grant hearing,” “patience in listening,” and “kindness of response” to those
whose complaints he had patiently listened to (Naz. 24). He was most excellent (commo-
dissimus) to hear embassies and complaints of provinces (Vict. Epit. p. 51),—a testimony
which is borne out by the facts. His Generosity is equally undoubted. His magnificent gifts
and largesses to the army were still remembered in the time of Julian (Orat. p. 13). His
constant and lavish giving to the Christians is Eusebius’ unending theme: but it was not to
the churches alone; for we read of his munificence to heathen tribes (V. C. 2. 22), his liber-
ality to the poor (V. C. 1. 43) in giving money for clothing, provision for orphans and widows,
marriage portions for virgins, compensation to losers in law suits (V. C. 4. 4). It was “scarcely
possible to be near him without benefit” (V. C. 1. 43; cf. V. C. 3. 16; 3. 22; 4. 44).
Though slow to serve some friends through suspicion (i.e. dubius thus explained), he
was “exceedingly generous towards others, neglecting no opportunity to add to their riches
1067
Moral Characteristics.