Chapter 3.—Whether Bodily Suffering Necessarily Terminates in the Destruction of
the Flesh.
But, say they, there is no body which can suffer and cannot also die. How do we know
this? For who can say with certainty that the devils do not suffer in their bodies, when they
own that they are grievously tormented? And if it is replied that there is no earthly
body—that is to say, no solid and perceptible body, or, in one word, no flesh—which can
suffer and cannot die, is not this to tell us only what men have gathered from experience
and their bodily senses? For they indeed have no acquaintance with any flesh but that which
is mortal; and this is their whole argument, that what they have had no experience of they
judge quite impossible. For we cannot call it reasoning to make pain a presumption of
death, while, in fact, it is rather a sign of life. For though it be a question whether that which
suffers can continue to live for ever, yet it is certain that everything which suffers pain does
live, and that pain can exist only in a living subject. It is necessary, therefore, that he who
is pained be living, not necessary that pain kill him; for every pain does not kill even those
mortal bodies of ours which are destined to die. And that any pain kills them is caused by
the circumstance that the soul is so connected with the body that it succumbs to great pain
and withdraws; for the structure of our members and vital parts is so infirm that it cannot
bear up against that violence which causes great or extreme agony. But in the life to come
this connection of soul and body is of such a kind, that as it is dissolved by no lapse of time,
so neither is it burst asunder by any pain. And so, although it be true that in this world
there is no flesh which can suffer pain and yet cannot die, yet in the world to come there
shall be flesh such as now there is not, as there will also be death such as now there is not.
For death will not be abolished, but will be eternal, since the soul will neither be able to enjoy
God and live, nor to die and escape the pains of the body. The first death drives the soul
from the body against her will: the second death holds the soul in the body against her will.
The two have this in common, that the soul suffers against her will what her own body inflicts.
Our opponents, too, make much of this, that in this world there is no flesh which can
suffer pain and cannot die; while they make nothing of the fact that there is something which
is greater than the body. For the spirit, whose presence animates and rules the body, can
both suffer pain and cannot die. Here then is something which, though it can feel pain, is
immortal. And this capacity, which we now see in the spirit of all, shall be hereafter in the
bodies of the damned. Moreover, if we attend to the matter a little more closely, we see that
what is called bodily pain is rather to be referred to the soul. For it is the soul not the body,
which is pained, even when the pain originates with the body,—the soul feeling pain at the
point where the body is hurt. As then we speak of bodies feeling and living, though the
feeling and life of the body are from the soul, so also we speak of bodies being pained, though
no pain can be suffered by the body apart from the soul. The soul, then, is pained with the
body in that part where something occurs to hurt it; and it is pained alone, though it be in
Whether Bodily Suffering Necessarily Terminates in the Destruction of the Flesh.
1020
Whether Bodily Suffering Necessarily Terminates in the Destruction of the…