Chapter 13.—18. But as regards the remission of sins, whether it is granted through
baptism at the hands of the heretics, I have already expressed my opinion on this point in
a former book;1286 but I will shortly recapitulate it here. If remission of sins is there conferred
by the sacredness of baptism, the sins return again through obstinate perseverance in heresy
or schism; and therefore such men must needs return to the peace of the Catholic Church,
that they may cease to be heretics and schismatics, and deserve that those sins which had
returned on them should be cleansed away by love working in the bond of unity. But if, al-
though among heretics and schismatics it be still the same baptism of Christ, it yet cannot
441
work remission of sins owing to this same foulness of discord and wickedness of dissent,
then the same baptism begins to be of avail for the remission of sins when they come to the
peace of the Church,—[not]1287 that what has been already truly remitted should not be
retained; nor that heretical baptism should be repudiated as belonging to a different religion,
or as being different from our own, so that a second baptism should be administered; but
that the very same baptism, which was working death by reason of discord outside the
Church, may work salvation by reason of the peace within. It was, in fact, the same savor
of which the apostle says, "We are a sweet savor of Christ in every place;" and yet, says he,
"both in them that are saved and in them that perish. To the one we are the savor of life
unto life; and to the other the savor of death unto death."1288 And although he used these
words with reference to another subject, I have applied them to this, that men may understand
that what is good may not only work life to those who use it aright, but also death to those
who use it wrong.
1286 Above, Book I. c. xi. sqq.
1287 Non ut jam vere dimissa non retineantur. One of the negatives here appears to be superfluous, and the
former is omitted in Amerbach’s edition, and in many of the Mss., which continue the sentence, "non ut ille
baptismus," instead of "neque ut ille," etc. If the latter negative were omitted, the sense would be improved, and
"neque" would appropriately remain.
1288 2 Cor. ii. 15, 16.
Chapter 13
767
Chapter 13