Chapter IX.
Various quibbling arguments, advanced by the Arians to show that the Son had a begin-
ning of existence, are considered and refuted, on the ground that whilst the Arians plainly
prove nothing, or if they prove anything, prove it against themselves, (inasmuch as He Who
is the beginning of all cannot Himself have a beginning), their reasonings do not even hold
true with regard to facts of human existence. Time could not be before He was, Who is the
Author of time—if indeed at some time He was not in existence, then the Father was without
His Power and Wisdom. Again, our own human experience shows that a person is said to
exist before he is born.
275
97. Now that our opponents have failed to maintain their objection against the truth of
His Son’s equality with the Father, on the ground of His Generation, let them see that their
well known device of controversy, their stock misrepresentation, is frustrated. Their common
use is to propound this riddle: “How can the Son be equal with the Father? If He is a Son,
then before He was begotten He was not in existence. If He was in existence, why was He
begotten?” And men who advance difficulties raised by Arius yet sturdily deny that they are
Arians.
98. Accordingly, they demand our answer, intending, if we say, “The Son existed before
He was begotten,” to meet us with a subtle retort, that “If so, then, before He was begotten,
He was created, and there is no difference between Him and the rest of created beings, for
He began to be a creature before He began to be the Son.” To which they add: “Why was
He begotten, when He was already in existence? Because He was imperfect, and in order
that He might afterwards be made more perfect?” Whilst if we reply that the Son did not
exist before He was begotten, they will immediately reply: “Then by being begotten He was
brought into existence, not having existed before He was begotten,” so as to lead on from
this to the conclusion that “the Son existed, when He did not exist.”1641
99. But let those who propound this difficulty and endeavour to enwrap the truth in a
cloud tell us themselves whether the Father exerts His power of begetting within or without
limits of time. If they say “within limits of time,” then they will attribute to the Father what
they object against the Son, so as to make the Father seem to have begun to be what He was
not before. If their answer is “without such limits,” then what is left them but to resolve for
themselves the problem they have propounded, and acknowledge that the Son is not begotten
under limits and conditions of time, since they deny that the Father so begets?
100. If the Son, then, is not begotten within limits of time, we are free to judge that
nothing can have existed before the Son, Whose being is not confined by time. If, indeed,
there was anything in being before the Son, then it instantly follows that in Him were not
created all things in heaven or in earth, and the Apostle is shown to have erred in so setting
1641 St. Ambrose exhibits the argument as a reductio ad absurdum.
Chapter IX. Various quibbling arguments, advanced by the Arians to show that the Son had a beginning of existence, are considered and refuted, on the ground that whilst the Arians plainly prove nothing, or if they prove anything, prove it against themselves, (inasmuch as He Who is the beginning of all cannot Himself have a beginning), their reasonings do not even hold true with regard to facts of human existence. Time could not be before He was, Who is the Author of time--if indeed at some time He was not in existence, then the Father was without His Power and Wisdom. Again, our own human experience shows that a person is said to exist before he is born.
612
Chapter IX. Various quibbling arguments, advanced by the Arians to show…