reasonably claims a right of possession, as it were, of the whole for itself: as, e.g., in the three
kinds of questions above mentioned,1463 although the question raised be whether a thing
is or not, this involves necessarily also both what it is (this or that), for of course it cannot
be at all unless it be something, and whether it ought to be approved of or disapproved of,
for whatever is is a fit subject for some opinion as to its quality; in like manner, when the
question raised is what a thing is, this necessarily involves both that it is, and that its quality
may be tried by some standard; and in the same way, when the question raised is what is
the quality of a thing, this necessarily involves that that thing is, and is something, since all
things are inseparably joined to themselves;—nevertheless, the question in each of the above
cases takes its name not from all the three, but from the special point towards which the
inquirer directed his attention. Now there is a certain training necessary for men, by which
they might be instructed and formed after some model. We cannot say, however, regarding
that which is accomplished in men by this training, either that it does not exist, or that it is
not a thing to be desired [i.e. we cannot say what it is, without involving an affirmation both
of its existence and of its quality]; but we seek first to know what it is, for in knowing this
we know that by which we may infer that it is something, and in which we may remain.
Therefore the first thing necessary was, that a certain rule and pattern of training be plainly
exhibited; and this was done by the divinely appointed method of the Incarnation, which
is properly to be ascribed to the Son, in order that from it should follow both our knowledge,
through the Son, of the Father Himself, i.e. of the one first principle whence all things have
their being, and a certain inward and ineffable charm and sweetness of remaining in that
knowledge, and of despising all mortal things,—a gift and work which is properly ascribed
to the Holy Spirit. Wherefore, although in all things the Divine Persons act perfectly in
common, and without possibility of separation, nevertheless their operations behoved to
be exhibited in such a way as to be distinguished from each other, on account of the weakness
which is in us, who have fallen from unity into variety. For no one ever succeeds in raising
another to the height on which he himself stands, unless he stoop somewhat towards the
level which that other occupies.
You have here a letter which may not indeed put an end to your disquietude in regard
to this doctrine, but which may set your own thoughts to work upon a kind of solid found-
ation; so that, with the talents which I well know you to possess, you may follow, and, by
the piety in which especially we must be stedfast, may apprehend that which still remains
to be discovered.
1463 An sit, quid sit, quale sit.
535
To Nebridius