than by a man of known chastity, it follows plainly, that whoever be the minister that dis-
penses the rite, the baptism is valid, because He Himself baptizes upon whom the dove
descended.
6. Notwithstanding the impression which truth so obvious should produce on the ears
and hearts of men, such is the whirlpool of evil custom by which some have been engulfed,
that rather than yield, they will resist both authority and argument of every kind. Their
resistance is of two kinds—either with active rage or with passive immobility. What remedies,
then, must the Church apply when seeking with a mother’s anxiety the salvation of them
all, and distracted by the frenzy of some and the lethargy of others? Is it right, is it possible,
for her to despise or give up any means which may promote their recovery? She must neces-
sarily be esteemed burdensome by both, just because she is the enemy of neither. For men
in frenzy do not like to be bound, and men in lethargy do not like to be stirred up; neverthe-
less the diligence of charity perseveres in restraining the one and stimulating the other, out
of love to both. Both are provoked, but both are loved; both, while they continue under their
infirmity, resent the treatment as vexatious; both express their thankfulness for it when they
are cured.
7. Moreover, whereas they think and boast that we receive them into the Church just
as they were, it is not so. We receive them completely changed, because they do not begin
to be Catholics until they have ceased to be heretics. For their sacraments, which we have
in common with them, are not the objects of dislike to us, because they are not human, but
Divine. That which must be taken from them is the error, which is their own, and which
they have wickedly imbibed; not the sacraments, which they have received like ourselves,
and which they bear and have,—to their own condemnation, indeed, because they use them
so unworthily; nevertheless, they truly have them. Wherefore, when their error is forsaken,
and the perversity of schism corrected in them, they pass over from heresy into the peace
of the Church, which they formerly did not possess, and without which all that they did
possess was only doing them harm. If, however, in thus passing over they are not sincere,
this is a matter not for us, but for God, to judge. And yet, some who were suspected of insin-
376
cerity because they had passed over to us through fear, have been found in some subsequent
temptations so faithful as to surpass others who had been originally Catholics. Therefore
let it not be said that nothing is accomplished when strong measures are employed. For
when the entrenchments of stubborn custom are stormed by fear of human authority, this
is not all that is done, because at the same time faith is strengthened, and the understanding
convinced, by authority and arguments which are Divine.
8. These things being so, be it known to your Grace that your men in the region of Hippo
are still Donatists, and that your letter has had no influence upon them. The reason why it
failed to move them I need not write; but send some one, either a servant or a friend of your
own, whose fidelity you can entrust with the commission, and let him come not to them in
833
To Festus