church of God; and some suppose, the worshippers of Baal in Israel, even those who were
bred up such from their infancy, remained still members of the church of God. And very
many protestant divines suppose, that the members of the church of Rome, though they are
brought up and live continually in gross idolatry, and innumerable errors and superstitions
that tend utterly to make void the gospel of Christ, still are in the visible church of Christ:
yet, I suppose, no orthodox divines would hold these to be properly and regularly qualified
for the Lord’s supper. It was therefore requisite, in the question before us, that a distinction
should be made between the members of the visible church in general, and members in
complete standing.
It was also requisite, that such a distinction should be made in the question, to avoid
lengthening out this discourse exceedingly, with needless questions and debates concerning
the state of baptized infants; that is needless as to my present purpose. Though I have no
doubts about the doctrine of infant baptism; yet God’s manner of dealing with such infants
as are regularly dedicated to him in baptism, is a matter liable to great disputes and many
controversies, and would require a large dissertation by itself to clear it up; which, as it would
extend this discourse beyond all bounds, so it appears not necessary in order to a clear de-
termination of the present question. The revelation of God’s word is much plainer and more
express concerning adult persons, that act for themselves in religious matters, than concerning
infants. The Scriptures were written for the sake of adult persons, or those that are capable
of knowing what is written. It is to such the apostle speaks in the Epistles, and to such only
does God speak throughout his word; and the Scriptures especially speak for the sake of
these, and about those to whom they speak. And therefore if the word of God affords us
light enough concerning those spoken of in the question, as I have stated it, clearly to de-
termine the matter with respect to them, we need not wait till we see all doubts and contro-
versies about baptized infants cleared and settled, before we pass a judgment with respect
to the point in hand. The denominations, characters, and descriptions, which we find given
in the Scripture to visible Christians, and to the visible church, are principally with an eye
to the church of Christ in its adult state and proper standing. If any one was about to describe
that kind of birds called doves, it would be most proper to describe grown doves, and not
young ones in the egg or nest, without wings or feathers. So if any one should describe a
palm-tree or olive-tree by their visible form and appearance, it would be presumed that they
described those of these kinds of trees in their natural and proper state; and not as just
peeping from the ground, or as thunder-struck or blown down. And therefore I would here
give notice, once for all, that when in the ensuing discourse I use such like phrases as visible
saints, members of the visible church, &c. I, for the most part, mean persons that are adult
and in good standing.
The question is not, whether Christ has made converting grace or piety itself the condi-
tion or rule of his people’s admitting any to the privileges of members in full communion
1748
PART I. The Question stated and explained.