heretics and schismatics received into her bosom without baptism; nor again agree with
Cyprian himself, for he declared that he remained in communion with those who received
heretics and schismatics, and so also with those who were received as well: while they have
separated themselves from the communion of the whole world, on account of the charge
of having delivered up the sacred books, which they brought against the men whom they
maligned in Africa, but failed to convict when brought to trial beyond the sea; although,
even had the crimes which they alleged been true, they were much less heinous than the
sins of heresy and schism; and yet these could not defile Cyprian in the persons of those
who came from them without baptism, as he conceived, and were admitted without baptism
into the Catholic communion. Nor, in the very point in which they say that they imitate
Cyprian, can they find any answer to make about acknowledging the baptism of the followers
of Maximianus, together with those whom, though they belonged to the party that they had
first condemned in their own plenary Council, and then gone on to prosecute even at the
tribunal of the secular power, they yet received back into their communion, in the episcopate
of the very same bishop under whom they had been condemned. Wherefore, if the commu-
nion of wicked men destroyed the Church in the time of Cyprian, they have no source from
which they can derive their own communion; and if the Church was not destroyed, they
have no excuse for their separation from it. Moreover, they are neither following the example
of Cyprian, since they have burst the bond of unity, nor abiding by their own Council, since
they have recognized the baptism of the followers of Maximianus.
755
Chapter 2