To this I would reply, that such an evasion will not at all avail to the purpose of those
whom I oppose in this controversy. It alters not the case as to this question, Whether man,
in his present state, is depraved and ruined by propensities to sin. If any creature be of such
a nature that it proves evil in its proper place, or in the situation which God has assigned it
in the universe, it is of any evil nature. That part of the system is not good, which is not good
in its place in the system; and those inherent qualities of that part of the system, which are
not good, but corrupt, in that place, are justly looked upon as evil inherent qualities. That
propensity is truly esteemed to belong to the nature of any being, or to be inherent in it,
that is the necessary consequence of its nature, considered together with its proper situation
in the universal system of existence, whether that propensity be good or bad. It is the nature
of a stone to be heavy; but yet, if it were placed, as it might be, at a distance from this world,
it would have no such quality. But being a stone, is of such a nature, that it will have this
quality or tendency, in its proper place, in this world, where God has made it, it is properly
looked upon as a propensity belonging to its nature. And if it be a good propensity here, in
its proper place, then it is a good quality of its nature; but if it be contrariwise, it is an evil
natural quality. So, if mankind are of such a nature, that they have an universal effectual
tendency to sin and ruin in this world, where God has made and placed them, this is to be
looked upon as a pernicious tendency belonging to their nature. There is, perhaps, scarce
any such thing, in beings not independent and self-existent, as any power or tendency, but
what has some dependence on other beings, with which they stand connected in the universal
system of existence. Propensities are no propensities, any otherwise, than as taken with their
objects. Thus it is with the tendencies observed in natural bodies, such as gravity, magnetism,
electricity, &c. And thus it is with the propensities observed in the various kinds of animals;
and thus it is with most of the propensities in created spirits.
It may further be observed, that it is exactly the same thing, as to the controversy con-
cerning an agreeableness with God’s moral perfections of such a disposal of things—that
man should come into the world in a depraved and ruined state, by a propensity to sin and
ruin—whether God has so ordered it, that this propensity should lie in his nature considered
alone, or with relation to its situation in the universe, and its connexion with other parts of
the system to which the Creator has united it; which is as much of God’s ordering, as man’s
nature itself, most simply considered.
Dr. T. (p. 188, 189.) speaking of the attempt of some to solve the difficulty of God being
the author of our nature, and yet that our nature is polluted, by supposing that God makes
the soul pure, but unites it to a polluted body, (or a body so made, as tends to pollute the
soul,) he cries out of it as weak and insufficient, and too gross to be admitted: For, says he,
who infused the soul into the body? And if it is polluted by being infused into the body, who
is the author and cause of its pollution? And who created the body? &c.—But is not the case
just the same, as to those who suppose that God made the soul pure, and places it in a polluted
947
SECTION II. Universal sin proves a sinful propensity.