XXVIII. To those who say that souls existed before bodies, or that bodies were formed
before souls; wherein there is also a refutation of the fables concerning transmigration of
souls1729.
1. For it is perhaps not beyond our present subject to discuss the question which has
been raised in the churches touching soul and body. Some of those before our time who
have dealt with the question of “principles” think it right to say that souls have a previous
existence as a people in a society of their own, and that among them also there are standards
of vice and of virtue, and that the soul there, which abides in goodness, remains without
experience of conjunction with the body; but if it does depart from its communion with
good, it falls down to this lower life, and so comes to be in a body. Others, on the contrary,
marking the order of the making of man as stated by Moses, say, that the soul is second to
the body in order of time, since God first took dust from the earth and formed man, and
then animated the being thus formed by His breath1730: and by this argument they prove
that the flesh is more noble than the soul; that which was previously formed than that which
was afterwards infused into it: for they say that the soul was made for the body, that the
thing formed might not be without breath and motion; and that everything that is made for
something else is surely less precious than that for which it is made, as the Gospel tells us
that “the soul is more than meat and the body than raiment1731,” because the latter things
exist for the sake of the former—for the soul was not made for meat nor our bodies for
raiment, but when the former things were already in being the latter were provided for their
needs.
2. Since then the doctrine involved in both these theories is open to criticism—the
doctrine alike of those who ascribe to souls a fabulous pre-existence in a special state, and
of those who think they were created at a later time than the bodies, it is perhaps necessary
to leave none of the statements contained in the doctrines without examination: yet to engage
and wrestle with the doctrines on each side completely, and to reveal all the absurdities in-
volved in the theories, would need a large expenditure both of argument and of time; we
shall, however, briefly survey as best we can each of the views mentioned, and then resume
our subject.
3. Those who stand by the former doctrine, and assert that the state of souls is prior to
their life in the flesh, do not seem to me to be clear from the fabulous doctrines of the heathen
which they hold on the subject of successive incorporation: for if one should search carefully,
he will find that their doctrine is of necessity brought down to this. They tell us that one of
1729 Otherwise Chap. xxix. The title in the Bodleian ms. of the Latin version is:—“Of different views of the
origin of the soul.”
1730 Cf. Gen. ii. 7
1731 S. Matt. vi. 25
To those who say that souls existed before bodies, or that bodies were formed before souls; wherein there is also a refutation of the fables concerning transmigration of souls.
780
To those who say that souls existed before bodies, or that bodies were formed…