CHAP. XX.] GENERATION OF THE SON NECESSARY. 423
nature or substance or essence, but the Son of tlie will of
God ; so as to mean to assert that the will by which he begat
the Son was something that happened to God,—to wit, in that
way that we ourselves sometimes will something which before
we did not will, as though it was not for these very things
that our nature is perceived to be changeable,—a thing which
far be it from us to believe of God. For it is written for no
other reason, "Many are the thoughts in the heart of man, but
the counsel of the Lord abideth for ever," ^ except that we
may understand or believe that as God is eternal, so is His
counsel for eternity, and therefore unchangeable, asHe himself
is. And what is said of thoughts can most truly be said also
of the will : there are many wills in the heart of man, but the
will of the Lord abideth for ever. Some, again, to escape
saying that the only-begotten Word is the Son of the counsel
or will of God, have af&rmed the same Word to be the counsel
or will itself of the Father. But it is better in my judgment
to say counsel of counsel, and will of will, as substance of
substance, wisdom of wisdom, that we may not be led into
that absurdity, which we have refuted already, and say that
the Son makes the Father wise or willing, if the Father has
not in His own substance either counsel or will. It was cer-
tainly a sharp answer that somebody gave to the heretic, who
most subtly asked him whether God begat the Son willingly
or imwillingly, in order that if he said unwillingly, it would
follow most absurdly that God was miserable ; but if willingly,
he would forthwith infer, as though by an invincible reason,
that at which he was aiming, viz. that He was the Son, not of
His nature, but of His will. But that other, with great wake-
fulness, demanded of him in turn, whether God the Father
wasGod willingly or unwillingly ; in order that if he answered
unwillingly, that misery would follow, which to believe of God
is sheer madness ; and if he said willingly, it would be replied
to him. Then He is God too by His own will, not by His
nature. What remained, then, except that he should hold his
peace, and discern that he was himself bound by his own
question in an insoluble bond ? But if any person in the
Trinity is also to be specially called the will of God, this
1 Prov. xix. 21.