that we ought to doubt everything, and ruled that man had not the power of comprehending
any truth; for so, not yet realizing their meaning, I also was fully persuaded that they thought
just as they are commonly held to do. And I did not fail frankly to restrain in my host that
assurance which I observed him to have in those fictions of which the works of Manichæus
are full. Notwithstanding, I was on terms of more intimate friendship with them than with
others who were not of this heresy. Nor did I defend it with my former ardour; still my fa-
miliarity with that sect (many of them being concealed in Rome) made me slower415 to seek
any other way,—particularly since I was hopeless of finding the truth, from which in Thy
Church, O Lord of heaven and earth, Creator of all things visible and invisible, they had
turned me aside,—and it seemed to me most unbecoming to believe Thee to have the form
of human flesh, and to be bounded by the bodily lineaments of our members. And because,
when I desired to meditate on my God, I knew not what to think of but a mass of bodies416
(for what was not such did not seem to me to be), this was the greatest and almost sole cause
of my inevitable error.
into the doctrine of the third Academic school. Arcesilas had been a pupil of Polemo when he was head of the
old Academy. Zeno also, dissatisfied with the cynical philosophy of Crates, had learnt Platonic doctrine from
Polemo, and was, as Cicero tells us (De Fin. iv. 16), greatly influenced by his teaching. Zeno, however, soon
founded his own school of Stoical philosophy, which was violently opposed by Arcesilas (Cicero, Acad. Post. i.
12). Arcesilas, according to Cicero (ibid.), taught his pupils that we cannot know anything, not even that we are
unable to know. It is exceedingly probable, however, that he taught esoterically the doctrines of Plato to those
of his pupils he thought able to receive them, keeping them back from the multitude because of the prevalence
of the new doctrine. This appears to have been Augustin’s view when he had arrived at a fuller knowledge of
their doctrines than that he possessed at the time referred to in his Confessions. In his treatises against the Aca-
demicians (iii. 17) he maintains the wisdom of Arcesilas in this matter. He says: “As the multitude are prone to
rush into false opinions, and, from being accustomed to bodies, readily, but to their hurt, believe everything to
be corporeal, this most acute and learned man determined rather to unteach those who had suffered from bad
teaching, than to teach those whom he did not think teachable.” Again, in the first of his Letters, alluding to
these treatises, he says: “It seems to me to be suitable enough to the times in which they flourished, that whatever
issued pure from the fountain-head of Platonic philosophy should be rather conducted into dark and thorny
thickets for the refreshment of a very few men, than left to flow in open meadow-land, where it would be im-
possible to keep it clear and pure from the inroads of the vulgar herd. I use the word ‘herd’ advisedly, for what
is more brutish than the opinion that the soul is material?” and more to the same purpose. In his De Civ. Dei,
xix 18, he contrasts the uncertainty ascribed to the doctrines of these teachers with the certainty of the Christian
faith. See Burton’s Bampton Lectures, note 33, and Archer Butler’s Ancient Philosophy, ii. 313, 348, etc. See also
vii. sec. 13, note, below.
415 See iii. sec. 21, above.
416 See iv. secs. 3, 12, and 31, above.
173
When He Had Left the Manichæans, He Retained His Depraved Opinions Concerning…