the examples of the servants of God in whose case these things were done, you either failed
to see, or were unwilling to see, or seeing and knowing, were silent, in a manner which I
know not how you will defend, about those instances of friendship felt by kings for the
saints? But if it were not that, as a defender of the basest cause, you are hindered by the
desire of building up falsehood, and thereby turned away either as unwilling or as ignorant
from the light of truth, there can be no doubt that you could, without any difficulty, recall
some good kings as well as some bad ones, and some friendly to the saints as well as some
unfriendly. And we cannot but wonder that your Circumcelliones thus throw themselves
from precipices. Who was running after you, I pray? What Macarius, what soldier was
pursuing you? Certainly none of our party thrust you into this abyss of falsehood. Why
then did you thus run headlong with your eyes shut, so that when you said, "What have you
to do with the kings of this world?" you did not add, In whom Christianity has often found
envy towards herself, instead of boldly venturing to say, "In whom Christianity has never
found anything save envy towards her?" Was it really true that you neither thought yourself,
nor considered that those who read your writings would think, how many instances of kings
there were that went against your views? Does he not know what he says?
205. Or do you think that, because those whom I have mentioned belonged to olden
times, therefore they form no argument against you, because you did not say, In whom
righteousness has never found anything save envy towards her, but "In whom Christianity
has never found anything saving envy towards her,"—meaning, perhaps, that it should be
understood that they began to show envy towards the righteous from the time when they
began to bear the name of Christians? What then is the meaning of those examples from
olden times, by which you even more imprudently wished to prove what you had so im-
prudently ventured to assert? For was it not before Christ was born in the world that the
Maccabees, and the three children, and Daniel, did and suffered what you told of them?
And again, why was it, as I asked just now, that you offered a petition to Julian, the undoubted
foe of Christianity? Why did you seek to recover the basilicas from him? Why did you de-
clare that only righteousness found a place with him? If it is the foe of Christianity that
hears such things as these, what then are they from whom he hears them? But it should be
observed that Constantine, who was certainly no foe to the name of Christian, but rather
rendered glorious by it, being mindful of the hope which he maintained in Christ, and de-
ciding most justly on behalf of His unity, was not worthy to be acknowledged by you, even
when you yourselves appealed to him. Both these were emperors in Christian times, but
yet not both of them were Christians. But if both of them were foes of Christianity, why
did you thus appeal to one of them? why did you thus present a petition to the other? For
on your ancestors making their petition, Constantine had given an episcopal judgment both
at Rome and at Arles; and yet the first of them you accused before him, from the other you
appealed to him. But if, as is the case, one of them had believed in Christ, the other had
1146
Chapter 93