struction, a more precise definition of its meaning, and a formal defence of its orthodoxy.
And herein consisted one principal service rendered by S. Basil and S. Gregory; while with
more precise definition of the term ὑπόστασις there emerged, it may be, a more precise view
of the relations of the Persons, and with the defence of the new phrase as expressive of the
Trinity of Persons a more precise view of what is implied in the Unity of the Godhead.
25
The treatise, De Sancta Trinitate is one of those which are attributed by some to S. Basil,
by others to S. Gregory: but for the purpose of showing the difficulties with which they had
to deal, the question of its exact authorship is unimportant. 43The most obvious objection
alleged against their teaching was that which had troubled the Western theologians before
the Alexandrine Council,—the objection that the acknowledgment of Three Persons implied
a belief in Three Gods. To meet this, there was required a statement of the meaning of the
term ὑπόστασις, and of the relation of ὀυσία to ὑπόστασις. Another objection, urged appar-
ently by the same party as the former, was directed against the “novelty,” or inconsistency,
of employing in the singular terms expressive of the Divine Nature such as “goodness” or
“Godhead,” while asserting that the Godhead exists in plurality of Persons44. To meet this,
it was required that the sense in which the Unity of the Godhead was maintained should be
more plainly and clearly defined.
The position taken by S. Basil with regard to the terms οὐσία and ὑπόστασις is very
concisely stated in his letter to Terentius45. He says that the Western theologians themselves
acknowledge that a distinction does exist between the two terms: and he briefly sets forth
his view of the nature of that distinction by saying that οὐσία is to ὑπόστασις as that which
is common to individuals is to that in respect of which the individuals are naturally differ-
entiated. He illustrates this statement by the remark that each individual man has his being
τῷ κοίνῳ τῆς οὐσίας λόγῳ, while he is differentiated as an individual man in virtue of his
own particular attributes. So in the Trinity that which constitutes the οὐσία (be it “goodness”
or be it “Godhead”) is common, while the ὑπόστασις is marked by the Personal attribute of
Fatherhood or Sonship or Sanctifying Power46. This position is also adopted and set forth
43 It appears on the whole more probable that the treatise is the work of S. Gregory; but it is found, in a slightly
different shape, among the Letters of S. Basil. (Ep. 189 in the Benedictine Edition.)
44 In what sense this language was charged with “novelty” is not very clear. But the point of the objection
appears to lie in a refusal to recognize that terms expressive of the Divine Nature, whether they indicate attributes
or operations of that Nature, may be predicated of each ὑπόστασις severally, as well as of the οὐσία, without at-
taching to the terms themselves that idea of plurality which, so far as they express attributes or operations of
the οὐσία, must be excluded from them.
45 S. Bas. Ep. 214, §4.
46 The differentia here assigned to the Third Person is not, in S. Basil’s own view, a differentia at all: for he
would no doubt have been ready to acknowledge that this attribute is common to all Three Persons. S. Gregory,
44
His Teaching on the Holy Trinity.