SECT. I.
Remarks on Dr. T.’s way of explaining this text.
The following things are worthy of notice, concerning our author’s exposition of this
remarkable passage.
I. He greatly insists, that by death in this place no more is meant, than that death which
we all die, when this present life is extinguished, and the body returns to the dust. That no
more is meant in Rom. v.12, 14, 15, 17, (p. 27.) he declares as evidently, clearly, and infallibly
so, because the apostle is till discoursing on the same subject; plainly implying, that infallibly
the apostle means no more by death, throughout this paragraph on the subject. But as infal-
lible as this is, if we believe what Dr. T. says elsewhere, it must needs be otherwise: for (p.
120. S) speaking of those words in Rom. vi. 23.“The wages of sin is death, but the gift of God
is eternal life, through Jesus Christ our Lord,” he says, “Death in this place is widely different
from the death we now die; as it stands there opposed to eternal life, which is the gift of God
through Jesus Christ, it manifestly signifies eternal death, the second death, or that death
which they shall hereafter die, who live after the flesh.” But the death (in the conclusion of
the paragraph we are upon) that comes by Adam, and the life that comes by Christ (in the
last verse of the chapter), is opposed to eternal life just in the same manner as in the last verse
of the next chapter: “That as sin has reigned unto death, even so might grace reign through
righteousness, unto eternal life, by Jesus Christ our Lord.” So that by our author’s own argu-
ment, death in this place also, is manifestly widely different from the death we now die, as it
stands here opposed to eternal life, through Jesus Christ; and signifies eternal death, the second
death. And yet this is a part of the same discourse, begun in Rom. v. 12; as reckoned by Dr.
T. himself in his division of paragraphs, in his paraphrase and notes on the epistle. So that
if we will follow him, and admit his reasonings in the various parts of his book, here is
manifest proof, against infallible evidence! So that it is true, the apostle throughout this
whole passage on the same subject, by death, evidently, clearly, and infallibly means no more
than that death we now die, when this life is extinguished; and yet by death, in some part of
this passage, is meant something widely different from the death we now die—manifestly
eternal death, the second death.
But had our author been more consistent with himself, in laying it down as certain and
infallible, that because the apostle has a special respect to temporal death, in ”Death reigned
from Adam to Moses,” 73 therefore he means no more in the several consequent parts of
this passage, yet he is doubtless too confident and positive in this matter. This is no more
evident, clear, and infallible, than that Christ meant by perishing—in Luke xiii. 5. when he
says, I tell you, Nay, but except ye repent, ye shall all likewise perish—no more than such a
temporal death, as came on those who died by the fall of the tower of Siloam, spoken of in
73 Rom. v. 14.
SECTION I. Remarks on Dr. Taylor's way of explaining this text.
1086
SECTION I. Remarks on Dr. Taylor's way of explaining this text.