191
Book VII.
§1. The seventh book shows from various statements made to the Corinthians and to the
Hebrews, and from the words of the Lord, that the word “Lord” is not expressive of essence,
according to Eunomius’ exposition, but of dignity. and after many notable remarks concerning
“the Spirit” and the Lord, he shows that Eunomius, from his own words, is found to argue in
favour of orthodoxy, though without intending it, and to be struck by his own shafts.
Since, however, Eunomius asserts that the word “Lord” is used in reference to the essence
and not to the dignity of the Only-begotten, and cites as a witness to this view the Apostle,
when he says to the Corinthians, “Now the Lord is the Spirit810,” it may perhaps be opportune
that we should not pass over even this error on his part without correction. He asserts that
the word “Lord” is significative of essence, and by way of proof of this assumption he brings
up the passage above mentioned. “The Lord,” it says, “is the Spirit811.” But our friend who
interprets Scripture at his own sweet will calls “Lordship” by the name of “essence,” and
thinks to bring his statement to proof by means of the words quoted. Well, if it had been
said by Paul, “Now the Lord is essence,” we too would have concurred in his argument. But
seeing that the inspired writing on the one side says, “the Lord is the Spirit,” and Eunomius
says on the other, “Lordship is essence,” I do not know where he finds support for his
statement, unless he is prepared to say again812 that the word “Spirit” stands in Scripture
for “essence.” Let us consider, then, whether the Apostle anywhere, in his use of the term
“Spirit,” employs that word to indicate “essence.” He says, “The Spirit itself beareth witness
with our Spirit813,” and “no one knoweth the things of a man save the Spirit of man which
is in him814,” and “the letter killeth, but the Spirit giveth life815,” and “if ye through the
Spirit do mortify the deeds of the body, ye shall live816,” and “if we live in the Spirit let us
also walk in the Spirit817.” Who indeed could count the utterances of the Apostle on this
point? and in them we nowhere find “essence” signified by this word. For he who says that
“the Spirit itself beareth witness with our spirit,” signifies nothing else than the Holy Spirit
Which comes to be in the mind of the faithful; for in many other passages of his writings
he gives the name of spirit to the mind, on the reception by which of the communion of the
810 2 Cor. iii. 17.
811 2 Cor. iii. 17.
812 It is not quite clear whether πάλιν is to be constructed with λέγοι or with κεῖσθαι, but the difference in
sense is slight.
813 Rom. viii. 16.
814 1 Cor. ii. 11.
815 2 Cor. iii. 6.
816 Rom. viii. 13.
817 Gal. v. 25.
Book VIIThe seventh book shows from various statements made to the Corinthians and to the Hebrews, and from the words of the Lord, that the word “Lord” is not expressive of essence, according to Eunomius' exposition, but of dignity. and after many notable remarks concerning “the Spirit” and the Lord, he shows that Eunomius, from his own words, is found to argue in favour of orthodoxy, though without intending it, and to be struck by his own shafts.
367
Book VII