270 THE SEVEN BOOKS OF [Book v1.
the heathen said, by means of their images. Can the gods, therefore,
Arnobius asks, receive homage only when offered to statues? What
can be more insulting than to believe in a god, and pray to a statue,
to hope for aid from a deity, but to ask it from his image (9)? More-
over, how could it be known that those figures were indeed images of
the gods? The moon is ever in motion; how could the figure of a woman
which never stirred be her likeness? But if the gods were not such as
their statues—which no one supposed—what audacity was shown in
giving to them whatever figures men pleased (10)! Little occasion had
they to laugh at the superstitious worship of rivers, stones, sabres, and
pieces of wood by ancient and barbarous peoples, while they themselves
prayed to little figures of men. Did they, then, believe that the gods
were like men? No, Arnobius says; only they found themselves com-
mitted to a false position, and would rather maintain it with violence
and cruelty than admit that they were in error (11). Hence it was that
such extraordinary forms and equipments were given to the gods. But
if the images were secretly removed from their proper places, and the
insignia of one given to another, it would be impossible to say which
was Jupiter, which Mars. How absurd to form images of the gods,
which depend for their individuality on the dresses put upon them (12)!
It was a small thing, however, to distinguish the gods by means of reap-
ing-hooks, tridents, horns, or hammers ; but it was no light matter that
the gods should be fashioned like lewd men and women, and that thus
divine honours should be paid to harlots (13). Arnobius next insists that
images are but dead matter, moulded, cut, filed, and hewn into form by
men; and that it is therefore absurd for a man to worship what he has
himself made (14). No one would worship, he says, a mass of metal or a
heap of stones, or even fragments of images; but why, while the parts
are thus regarded as merely dead matter, should they, when formed into
an image, become divine (15) ? Still men asked blessings from earthen-
ware, copper, and ivory, and supposed that their prayers were heard by
senseless figures, forgetting how and from what they were formed ; that
it was man's skill which gave them all their grandeur, for within them
there was only hideous emptiness; and that they were destroyed by
time, used as coverts by mean and loathsome creatures, and bemired by
birds, the dumb animals thus teaching their master, man, that the images
which he worshipped were beneath his notice (16). But, was the reply
of the heathen, we worship not the images, but the deities, which are
brought into them by their consecration. Do the gods, then, quit heaven
to give dignity to what is base? And if so, do they enter these images
willingly or unwillingly? 1f unwillingly, is their majesty not lessened ?
If willingly, what can they find there to entice them from their starry
seats (17)? It is further asked, Do the gods always remain in these
images, or come and go at will? If the former, how wretched is their
case! If the latter, how is it to be known when the god is in the image