Chapter 4.—6. We do not, therefore, "acknowledge the baptism of heretics,"1351 when
we refuse to baptize after them; but because we acknowledge the ordinance to be of Christ
even among evil men, whether openly separated from us, or secretly severed whilst within
our body, we receive it with due respect, having corrected those who were wrong in the
points wherein they went astray. However as I seem to be hard pressed when it is said to
me, "Does then a heretic confer remission of sins?" so I in turn press hard when I say, Does
then he who violates the commands of Heaven, the avaricious man, the robber, the usurer,
the envious man, does he who renounces the world in words and not in deeds, confer such
remission? If you mean by the force of God’s sacrament, then both the one and the other;
if by his own merit, neither of them. For that sacrament, even in the hands of wicked men,
is known to be of Christ; but neither the one nor the other of these men is found in the body
of the one uncorrupt, holy, chaste dove, which has neither spot nor wrinkle. And just as
baptism is of no profit to the man who renounces the world in words and not in deeds, so
it is of no profit to him who is baptized in heresy or schism; but each of them, when he
amends his ways, begins to receive profit from that which before was not profitable, but was
yet already in him.
7. "He therefore that is baptized in heresy does not become the temple of God;1352 but
does it therefore follow that he is not to be considered as baptized? For neither does the
avaricious man, baptized within the Church, become the temple of God unless he depart
from his avarice; for they who become the temple of God certainly inherit the kingdom of
449
God. But the apostle says, among many other things, "Neither the covetous, nor extortioners,
shall inherit the kingdom of God."1353 For in another place the same apostle compares
covetousness to the worship of idols: "Nor covetous man," he says, "who is an idolater;"1354
which meaning the same Cyprian has so far extended in a letter to Antonianus, that he did
not hesitate to compare the sin of covetousness with that of men who in time of persecution
had declared in writing that they would offer incense.1355 The man, then, who is baptized
in heresy in the name of the Holy Trinity, yet does not become the temple of God unless he
abandons his heresy, just as the covetous man who has been baptized in the same name
does not become the temple of God unless he abandons his covetousness, which is idolatry.
For this, too, the same apostle says: "What agreement hath the temple of God with idols?"1356
Let it not, then, be asked of us "of what God he is made the temple"1357 when we say that
1351 Ib., lxiii. 12, quando a nobis baptisma eorum in acceptum refertur.
1352 Cypr. Ep. lxxvii. 12.
1353 1 Cor. vi. 10.
1354 Eph. v. 5.
1355 Cypr. Ep. lv. 26.
1356 2 Cor. vi. 16.
1357 Cypr. Ep. lxxvii. 12.
Chapter 4
786
Chapter 4