diculous. Again I must repeat his words: “If Father is the same as Ungenerate, it is allowable
for us to drop it, and use Ungenerate instead; thus, the Ungenerate is Ungenerate of the
Son; for as the Ungenerate is Father of the Son, so, reversely, the Father is Ungenerate of
the Son.” But let us turn the laugh against him, by reversing his quibble; thus: If Father is
not the same as Ungenerate, the Son of the Father will not be Son of the Ungenerate; for
having relation to the Father only, he will be altogether alien in nature to that which is other
than Father, and does not suit that idea; so that, if the Father is something other than the
Ungenerate, and the title Father does not comprehend that meaning, the Son, being One,
cannot be distributed between these two relationships, and be at the same time Son both of
the Father and of the Ungenerate; and, as before it was an acknowledged absurdity to speak
of the Deity as Ungenerate of the Son, so in this converse proposition it will be found an
absurdity just as great to call the Only-begotten Son of the Ungenerate. So that he must
choose one of two things; either the Father is the same as the Ungenerate (which is necessary
in order that the Son of the Father may be Son of the Ungenerate as well); and then our
doctrine has been ridiculed by him without reason; or, the Father is something different to
the Ungenerate, and the Son of the Father is alienated from all relationship to the Ungenerate.
But then, if it is thus to hold that the Only-begotten is not the Son of the Ungenerate, logic
inevitably points to a “generated Father;” for that which exists, but does not exist without
generation, must have a generated substance. If, then, the Father, being according to these
men other than Ungenerate, is therefore generated, where is their much talked of Ungener-
acy? Where is that basis and foundation of their heretical castle-building? The Ungenerate,
which they thought just now that they grasped, has eluded them, and vanished quite beneath
the action of a few barren syllogisms; their would-be demonstration of the Unlikeness, like
a mere dream about something, slips away at the touch of criticism, and takes its flight along
with this Ungenerate.
Thus it is that whenever a falsehood is welcomed in preference to the truth, it may indeed
flourish for a little through the illusion which it creates, but it will soon collapse; its own
methods of proof will dissolve it. But we bring this forward only to raise a smile at the very
pretty revenge we might take on their Unlikeness. We must now resume the main thread of
our discourse.
176
Several ways of controverting his quibbling syllogisms.