transfer the whole matter to the people belonging to the party of Majorinus,1636 that is, to
the seditious multitude who were opposed to the peace of the Church, in order, forsooth,
that Cæcilianus might be accused by that crowd which they believed to be powerful enough
to bend aside to their views the minds of the judges by mere turbulent clamour, without
any documentary evidence or examination as to the truth; unless it was likely that true ac-
cusations should be brought against Cæcilianus by a multitude infuriated and infatuated
by the cup of error and wickedness, in a place where seventy bishops had with insane pre-
cipitancy condemned, in their absence, men who were their peers, and who were innocent,
as was proved in the case of Felix of Aptunga. They wished to have Cæcilianus accused by
a mob such as that to which they had given way themselves, when they pronounced sentence
upon parties who were absent, and who had not been examined. But assuredly they had not
come to judges who could be persuaded to such madness.
15. Your own prudence may enable you to remark here both the obstinacy of these men,
and the wisdom of the judges, who to the last persisted in refusing to admit accusations
against Cæcilianus from the populace who were of the faction of Majorinus, who had no
281
legal standing in the case. You will also remark how they were required to bring forward
the men who had come with them from Africa as accusers or witnesses, or in some other
connection with the case, and how it was said that they had been present, but had been
withdrawn by Donatus. The said Donatus promised that he would produce them, and this
promise he made repeatedly; yet, after all, declined to appear again in presence of that
tribunal before which he had already confessed so much, that it seemed as if by his refusal
to return he desired only to avoid being present to hear himself condemned; but the things
for which he was to be condemned had been proved against him in his own presence, and
after examination. Besides this, a libel bringing charges against Cæcilianus was handed in
by some parties. How the inquiry was thereupon opened anew, what persons brought up
the libel, and how nothing after all could be proved against Cæcilianus, I need not state,
seeing that you have heard it all, and can read it as often as you please.
16. As to the fact that there were seventy bishops in the Council [which condemned
Cæcilianus], you remember what was said in the way of pleading against him the venerable
authority of so great a number. Nevertheless these most venerable men resolved to keep
their judgment unembarrassed by endless questions of hopeless intricacy, and did not care
to inquire either what was the number of those bishops, or whence they had been collected,
when they saw them to be blinded with such reckless presumption as to pronounce rash
sentence upon their peers in their absence, and without having examined them. And yet
what a decision was finally pronounced by the blessed Melchiades himself; how equitable,
how complete, how prudent, and how fitted to make peace! For he did not presume to depose
1636 Ordained by the Donatists bishop of Carthage in room of Cæcilianus.
638
To Glorius, Eleusius, etc.