CLXII. Letter
of Theodoretus to Andreas, Bishop of Samosata, written from
Ephesus.
2268
Writing from Ephesus I salute
your holiness, I congratulate you on your infirmity, and deem you dear
to God, in that you have known what evil deeds have been going on here
by report, and not by personal experience. Evil indeed! They transcend
all imagination and all incidents of history; they compel a continual
downpour of tears. The body of the Church is in peril of
dismemberment;—nay, rather I may say it has received the first
incision;—unless the wise Healer restore and re-connect the
unsound and severed limbs. Once again the Egyptian is raging against
God, and warring with Moses and Aaron His servants, and the more part
of Israel are on the side of the foe; for all too few are the sound who
willingly suffer for true religion’s sake. Ancient principles are
trodden under foot. Deposed men perform priestly functions, and they
who have deposed them sit sighing at home. Men excommunicated by the
same sentence as the deposed have relieved the deposed of their
deposition of their own free will. Such is the mockery of a synod held
by Egyptians, by Palestinians, by men from the Pontic and Asian
dioceses, and by the West in their company.
2269
What players in a pantomime, in
the days of paganism, even in any farce so held up religion to
ridicule? Indeed what farce-writer ever performed such a play? What
dramatist ever wrote so sad a tragedy? Such and so great are the
troubles that have beset God’s Church, whereof I have narrated
but a very small part.
2268
This letter may be dated “towards the end of July or in the
beginning of August 431, after the restitution of Cyril and Memnon on
July 16, and before the departure of Theodoret from Ephesus on August
20.” Garnerius. Andrew of Samosata wrote objections to
Cyril’s Chapters in the name of the bishops of the East. He was
prevented by illness from being present at Ephesus in 431, as he was
also from the synod assembled at Antioch in 444 to hear the cause of
Athanasius of Perrha. He was a warm supporter of Nestorius.
This letter exists only
in the Latin Version, and is to be found also in Mansi Collect. Conc.
ix. 293.
2269
In Ep. CLXI, the numbers are specified;—“Of Egyptians
fifty; of Asiani under Memnon, leader of the tyranny, forty; of the
heretics in Pamphylia called Messalianitæ, twelve; besides those
attached to the same metropolitan” (i.e. Amphilochius of Side)
“and others deposed and excommunicated in divers places by synods
or bishops, who constitute nothing but a mere turbulent and disorderly
mob, entirely ignorant of the divine decrees.”