CHAP. XXVIL] generation AND PROCESSION. 43*5
wrote it down. For when, among other things, I had taught
them by testimonies of the Holy Scriptures that the Holy
Spirit proceeds from both, I continue : " If, then, the Holy
Spirit proceeds both from the Father and from the Son, why
did the Son say, 'He proceedeth from the Father'?^ Why,
think you, except as He is wont to refer to Him, that also
which is His own, from whom also He Himself is ? Whence
also is that which He saith, 'My doctrine is not mine own,
but His that sent me
'?''^
If, therefore, it is His doctrine that
is here understood, which yet He said was not His own, but
His that sent Him, how much more is it there to be under-
stood that the Holy Spirit proceeds also from Himself, where
He so says. He proceedeth from the Father, as not to say. He
proceedeth not from me ? From Him, certainly, from whom
the Son had his Divine nature, for He is God of God, He has
also, that from Him too proceeds the Holy Spirit ; and hence
the Holy Spirit has from the Father Himself, that He should
proceed from the Son also, as He proceeds from the Father.
Here, too, in some way may this also be understood, so far as
it can be understood by such as we are, why the Holy Spirit
is not said to be born, but rather to proceed ; since if He, too,
was called a Son, He would certainly be called the Son of
both, which is most absurd, since no one is son of two, save
of father and mother. But far be it from us to surmise,any
such thing as this between God the Father and God the Son.
Because not even the son of men proceeds at the same time
from both father and mother ; but when he proceeds from the
father into the mother, he does not at that time proceed from
the mother ; and when he proceeds from the mother into this
present light, he does not at that time proceed from the father.
But the Holy Spirit does not proceed from the Father into the
Son, and from the Son proceed to sanctify the creature, but
proceeds at once from both ; although the Father has given
this to the Son, that He should proceed, as from Himself, so
also from Him. For we cannot say that the Holy Spirit is
not life, while the Father is life, and the Son is life : and
hence as the Father, while He has life in Himself, has given
also to the Son to have life in Himself; so has He given also
1 John XV. 26. 2 j^i^^ vii. 16.