if they are well watered. The riches must have been abundant, and they must have been
secure from harm; for there could be no fear of hailstorms when there were no light-
gatherers who, in your fable, set the thunder in motion.
270
13. Nor would the beings in this race of darkness have sought for food if it had not been
sweet and pleasant, so that they would have died from want. For we find that all bodies
have their peculiar wants, according to which food is either agreeable or offensive. If it is
agreeable, it is said to be sweet or pleasant; if it is offensive, it is said to be bitter or sour, or
in some way disagreeable. In human beings we find that one desires food which another
dislikes, from a difference in constitution or habit or state of health. Still more, animals of
quite different make can find pleasure in food which is disagreeable to us. Why else should
the goats feed so eagerly on the wild olives? This food is sweet to them, as in some sicknesses
honey tastes bitter to us. To a thoughtful inquirer these things suggest the beauty of the
arrangement in which each finds what suits it, and the greatness of the good which extends
from the lowest to the highest, and from the material to the spiritual. As for the race of
darkness, if an animal sprung from any element fed on what was produced by that element,
doubtless the food must have been sweet from its appropriateness. Again, if this animal
had found food of another element, the want of appropriateness would have appeared in
its offensiveness to the taste. Such offensiveness is called sourness, or bitterness, or disagree-
ableness, or something of the kind; or if its adverse nature is such as to destroy the harmony
of the bodily constitution, and so take away life or reduce the strength, it is called poison,
simply on account of this want of appropriateness, while it may nourish the kind of life to
which it is appropriate. So, if a hawk eat the bread which is our daily food, it dies; and we
die if we eat hellebore, which cattle often feed on, and which may itself in a certain form be
used as a medicine. If Faustus had known or thought of this, he would not have given
poison and antidote as an example of the two natures of good and evil, as if God were the
antidote and Hyle the poison. For the same thing, of one and the same nature, kills or cures,
as it is used appropriately or inappropriately. In the Manichæan legends, their god might
be said to have been poison to the race of darkness; for he so injured their bodies, that from
being strong, they became utterly feeble. But then again, as the light was itself taken, and
subjected to loss and injury, it may be said to have been poison to itself.
14. Instead of one good and one evil principle, you seem to make both good or both
evil, or rather two good and two evil; for they are good in themselves, and evil to one another.
We may see afterwards which is the better or the worse; but meanwhile we may think of
them as both good in themselves. Thus God reigned in one region, while Hyle reigned in
the other. There was health in both kingdoms, and rich produce in both; both had a numer-
ous progeny, and both tasted the sweetness of pleasures suitable to their respective natures.
But the race of darkness, say the Manichæans, excepting the part which was evil to the light
which it bordered on, was also evil to itself. As, however, I have already pointed out many
460
Faustus denies that Manichæans believe in two gods. Hyle no god. Augustin…