omnium. And I shall only add here, if it be allowed a just expectation that the candidate for
the communion examine himself about the same things at least as the pastor, to whom he
applies for admission, ought to make the subject of his examination, then it was worth while
to hear the opinion of those unnamed ministers in New England, (among whom the late Dr.
Colman, I have reason to think, was the principal,) that answered Dr. Mather’s Order of the
Gospel, (anno 1700,) who, in the Postscript to their Review, thus express themselves: ”We
highly approve—that the proponant of the Lord’s table be examined of his baptismal vow;
his sense of spiritual wants, sinfulness, and wretchedness; his hope, faith, experiences, resol-
utions through the grace of God.” This, I think, is something beyond Mr. Stoddard.
480
Quest. II. Whether it be the general opinion of those aforesaid, that some who know
themselves to be unregenerate, and under the reigning power of sin, ought notwithstanding,
in such a state, to come to the Lord’s table?
Answ. I am aware, Sir, though you have seen fit to take no notice of it to me, that Mr.
Stoddard (in his Doctrine of Instituted Churches) is peremptory in the affirmative; but I have
met with no author among Calvinists, at home or abroad, consenting with him, unless it be
Mr. Blake, and some that were for a promiscuous admission, with little or no limitation. If
divines in general, of the Calvinistic character, were for such a latitude as Mr. Stoddard’s,
what can we suppose to be the reason, that in treating on the Lord’s supper, they so constantly
consider it as one of the rights of the church, belonging to the truly faithful alone, exclusively
of all others? Why do we hear them declaring, It is certain that the right of external fellowship
resides in the faithful only: and as to the rest, they are in that communion only by accident,
and it is also only by accident that they are suffered there; but being what they are, they have
not any part in the rights of that society properly belonging to them? If they thought the sac-
rament instituted for conversion, why do we never find them recommending it as a converting
ordinance, and urging persons to come to it with that view, who know themselves to be in
an unconverted state? If they thought that any such have a right before God, and may come
to it with a good conscience, why do we find them so solemnly warning all that are truly
convinced of their remaining yet in a natural state, to refrain coming to the Lord’s table in
their unbelief and impenitence; as if they judged it a sinful and dangerous thing for them to
come under such circumstances? I know Mr. Stoddard, in his Appeal, disputes the fact. But
it has occurred to me in abundance of instances, while reviewing my authors on this occasion.
Among the foreign protestants in Germany, France, &c. I shall name but two out of
many instances before me. The Heidelberg or Palatine Catechism, which had the solemn
approbation of the synod of Dort, and was especially praised by the divines of Great Britain;
which has been in a manner universally received and taught, formerly in Scotland, and still
all over Holland, and by reason of its excellency has been translated into no less than thirteen
several languages; this is most express in claiming the Lord’s supper for a special privilege
of such as have true faith and repentance; and forbidding it to hypocrites, as well as scandalous
1880
Appendix. Mr. Foxcroft's letter.