Translator’s Introductory Notice.
————————————
Our
aim in these translations
has been to give a rendering of the original as literal as possible;
and to this we have adhered even in cases—and they are not a
few—in which the Latin or the Greek is not in strict accordance
with grammatical rule. It was thought advisable in all cases to
give the reader the means of forming an accurate estimate of the style
as well as the substance of these curious documents.
Part I.—Apocryphal
Gospels.
The portion of the volume, extending from page 361
to page 476, comprising the Apocryphal Gospels properly so called,
consists of twenty-two separate documents, of which ten are written in
Greek and twelve in Latin. These twenty-two may be classed under
three heads: (a) those relating to the history of Joseph and of
the Virgin Mary, previous to the birth of Christ; (b) those relating to
the infancy of the Saviour; and (c) those relating to the history of
Pilate. The
origines
of the traditions are the
Protevangelium of James, the Gospel of Thomas, and the Acts of
Pilate. All or most of the others can be referred to these three,
as compilations, modifications, or amplifications.
There is abundant evidence of the existence of many of
these traditions in the second century, though it cannot be made out
that any of the books were then in existence in their present
form. The greater number of the authorities on the subject,
however, seem to agree in assigning to the first four centuries of the
Christian era, the following five books: 1. The Protevangelium of
James; 2. The Gospel of Pseudo-Matthew; 4. The History of Joseph the
Carpenter; 5. The Gospel of Thomas; 9. The Gospel of Nicodemus.
We proceed to give a very brief notice of each of
them.
I.
The Protevangelium of
James
.—The name of Protevangelium was first given to it by
Postel, whose Latin version was published in 1552. The James is
usually referred to St. James the Less, the Lord’s brother; but
the titles vary very much.
1550
Origen, in the
end of the second century, mentions a book of James, but it is by no
means clear that he refers to the book in question. Justin
Martyr, in two passages, refers to the cave in which Christ was born;
and from the end of the fourth century down, there are numerous
allusions in ecclesiastical writings to statements made in the
Protevangelium.
For his edition Tischendorf made use of seventeen
mss.
, one of them belonging to the ninth
century. The Greek is good of the kind, and free from errors and
corruptions. There are translations of it into English by Jones
(1722) and Cowper (1867).
II.
The Gospel of
Pseudo-Matthew
.—The majority of the
mss.
attribute this book to Matthew, though the titles vary
much. The letters prefixed, professing to be written to and by
St. Jerome, exist in several of the
mss.
; but
no one who is acquainted with the style of Jerome’s letters will
think this one authentic. There are, however, in his works many
allusions to some of the legends mentioned in this book. Chapter
i.–xxiv. were edited by Thilo, chapters xxv. to the end are
edited
for the first time by
Tischendorf. It is not very clear whether the Latin be original,
or a direct translation from the Greek. In most part it seems to
be original. The list of epithets, however, applied to the
triangles of the Alpha in chapter xxxi. are pretty obviously
mistranslations of Greek technical terms, which it might not be
difficult to reproduce.
III.
Gospel of the Nativity of
Mary
.—This work, which is in substance the same as the
earlier part of the preceding, yet differs from it in several important
points, indicating a later date and a different author. It has
acquired great celebrity from having been transferred almost entire to
the
Historia Lombardica
or
Legenda Aurea
in the end of
the thirteenth century. Mediæval poetry and sacred art have
been very much indebted to its pages.
The original is in Latin, and is not a direct
translation from the Greek. In many passages it follows very
closely the Vulgate translation.
IV.
The History of Joseph the
Carpenter
.—The original language of this history is
Coptic. From the Coptic it was translated into Arabic. The
Arabic was published by Wallin in 1722, with a Latin translation and
copious notes. Wallin’s version has been republished by
Fabricius, and later in a somewhat amended form by Thilo. This
amended form of Wallin’s version is the text adopted by
Tischendorf. Chapters xiv.–xxiii. have been published in
the Sahidic text by Zoega in 1810 with a Latin translation, and more
correctly by Dulaurier in 1835 with a French translation.
Tischendorf employs various arguments in support of his
opinion that the work belongs to the fourth century. It is found,
he says, in both dialects of the Coptic: the eschatology of it is
not inconsistent with an early date: the feast of the thousand
years of chapter xxvi. had become part of heretical opinion after the
third century. The death of the Virgin Mary in chapter v. is
consistent with the doctrine of the assumption, which began to prevail
in the fifth century.
V., VI., VII.
The Gospel of
Thomas
.—Like the Protevangelium of James, the Gospel of
Thomas is of undoubted antiquity. It is mentioned by name by
Origen, quoted by Irenæus and the author of the Philosophumena,
who says that it was used by the Nachashenes, a Gnostic sect of the
second century. Cyril of Jerusalem (
d
. 386) attributes the
authorship not to the apostle, but to a Thomas who was one of the three
disciples of Manes. This fact, of course, indicates that Cyril
knew nothing of the antiquity of the book he was speaking of.
This Manichæan origin has been adopted by many writers, of whom
the best known are in recent times R. Simon and Mingarelli.
The text of the first Greek form is obtained from
a Bologna
ms.
published by Mingarelli with a
Latin translation in 1764, a Dresden
ms.
of the
sixteenth century edited by Thilo, a Viennese fragment edited by
Lambecius, and a Parisian fragment first brought to light by Coteler in
his, edition of the Apostolical Constitutions, and translated into
English by Jones.
The second Greek form is published for the first
time by Tischendorf, who got the
ms.
, which is
on paper, of the fourteenth or fifteenth century, from one of the
monasteries on Mount Sinai.
The Latin form is also published for the first
time, from a Vatican
ms.
There is another
Latin text existing in a palimpsest, which Tischendorf assigns to the
fifth century, and asserts to be much nearer the ancient Greek copy
than any of the other
mss.
It seems pretty clear, from the contents of the book,
that its author was a Gnostic, a Docetist, and a Marcosian; and it was
held in estimation by the Nachashenes and the Manichæans.
Its bearing upon Christian art, and to some extent Christian dogma, is
well known.
The Greek of the original is by no means good, and the
Latin translator has in many cases mistaken the meaning of common Greek
words
VIII.
Arabic Gospel of the
Saviour’s Infancy
.—Chapters i.–ix. are founded on
the Gospels of Luke and Matthew, and on the Protevangelium of James;
chapters xxxvi. to the end are com
piled from the Gospel of Thomas; the rest
of the book, chapters x. to xxxv., is thoroughly Oriental in its
character, reminding one of the tales of the
Arabian Nights
, or
of the episodes in the
Golden Ass
of Apuleius.
It is evident that the work is a compilation, and that
the compiler was an Oriental. Various arguments are adduced to
prove that the original language of it was Syriac.
It was first published, with a Latin translation and
copious notes, by Professor Sike of Cambridge in 1697, afterwards by
Fabricius, Jones, Schmid, and Thilo. Tischendorf’s text is
Sike’s Latin version amended by Fleischer.
There are not sufficient data for fixing with any
accuracy the time at which it was composed or compiled.
IX.–XIV.
The Gospel of
Nicodemus
.
1551
—The six
documents inserted under this name are various forms of two
books—two in Greek and one in Latin of the Acts of Pilate; one in
Greek and two in Latin of the Descent of Christ to the world
below. Of twelve
mss.
, only two or three
give the second part consecutively with the first, nor does it so
appear in the Coptic translation. The title of Gospel of
Nicodemus does not appear before the thirteenth century.
Justin Martyr mentions a book called the Acts of Pilate,
and Eusebius informs us that the Emperor Maximim allowed or ordered a
book, composed by the pagans under this title, to be published in a
certain portion of the empire, and even to be taught in the schools;
but neither of these could have been the work under consideration.
Tischendorf attributes it to the second century, which
is probably too early, though without doubt the legend was formed by
the end of the second century. Maury (
Mém. de la Société des Antiq. de France,
t. xx.) places it in the beginning of the fifth century, from 405 to
420; and Renan (
Études d’Hist.
Relig
., p. 177) concurs in this opinion. An able
writer in the
Quarterly Review
(vol. cxvi.) assigns it to 439;
the author of the article Pilate, in Smith’s
Bible
Dictionary
, gives the end of the third century as the probable
date.
The author was probably a Hellenistic Jew converted to
Christianity, or, as Tischendorf and Maury conclude, a Christian imbued
with Judaic and Gnostic beliefs. The original language was most
probably Greek, though, as in the case of Pseudo-Matthew, the History
of Joseph the Carpenter, etc., the original language is, in many of the
prefaces, stated to have been Hebrew. Some think that Latin was
the original language, on the ground that Pilate would make his report
to the Emperor in that, the official, language. The Latin text we
have, however, is obviously a translation, made, moreover, by a man to
whom Greek was not very familiar, as is obvious from several instances
specified in our notes to the text.
The
editio princeps
of the Latin text is without
place or date, and it has been re-edited by Jones, Birch, Fabricius,
Thilo, and others. The Greek text of Part I., and of a portion of
Part II., was first published by Birch, and afterwards in a much
improved form, with the addition of copious notes and prolegomena, by
Thilo. The latter part of his prolegomena contains a full account
of the English, French, Italian, and German translations. For his
edition Tischendorf consulted thirty-nine ancient documents, of which a
full account is given in his Prolegomena, pp. lxxi.–lxxvi.
For an interesting account of these documents, see the
introduction to Mr. B. H. Cowper’s translation of the Apocryphal
Gospels, pp. lxxxv.–cii.
XV.
The Letter of Pontius
Pilate
.—The text is formed from four authorities, none of
them ancient. A translation of the Greek text of the same letter
will be found at p. 480.
XVI., XVII.
The Report of
Pilate
.—The first of these documents was first published by
Fabricius with a Latin translation; the second by Birch, and then by
Thilo. Tischendorf has
made use of five
mss.
, the earliest of the twelfth century. It does
not seem possible to assign the date.
XVIII.
The Paradosis of
Pilate
.—It has been well remarked by the author of the
article in the
Quarterly Review
above referred to, that the
early Church looked on Pilate with no unfavourable eye; that he is
favourably shown in the catacombs; that the early Fathers interpreted
him as a figure of the early Church, and held him to be guiltless of
Christ’s death; that the creeds do not condemn him, and the
Coptic Church has even made him a saint. He remarks also that
Dante finds punishments for Caiaphas and Annas, but not for
Pilate.
The text was first edited by Birch, and afterwards
by Thilo. Tischendorf makes use of five
mss.
, of which the earliest belongs to the twelfth
century.
XIX.
The Death of Pilate.
—This
is published for the first time by Tischendorf from a Latin
ms.
of the fourteenth century. The
language shows it to be of a late date. It appears almost entire
in the
Legenda Aurea
.
XX.
The Narrative of
Joseph
.—This history seems to have been popular in the middle
ages, if we may judge from the number of the Greek
mss.
of it which remain.
It was first published by Birch, and after him by
Thilo. For his edition Tischendorf made use of three
mss.
, of which the oldest belongs to the twelfth
century.
XXI.
The Avenging of the
Saviour
.—This version of the Legend of Veronica is written in
very barbarous Latin, probably of the seventh or eighth century.
An Anglo-Saxon version, which Tischendorf concludes to be derived from
the Latin, was edited and translated for the Cambridge Antiquarian
Society, by C. W. Goodwin, in 1851. The Anglo-Saxon text is from
a
ms.
in the Cambridge Library, one of a number
presented to the Cathedral of Exeter by Bishop Leofric in the beginning
of the eleventh century.
The reader will observe that there are in this
document two distinct legends, somewhat clumsily joined
together—that of Nathan’s embassy, and that of
Veronica.
1552
1550
[James the Lord’s
brother, in the earliest Christian literature, is not identified with
James the son of Alphæus, one of the twelve. On the titles,
see footnote on first page of text.—R.]
1551
[The numbers
here correspond with those of Tischendorf in his
prolegomena
. In his table of contents, however, he gives a
separate number to the letter of Pilate, which closes XIII. Hence
the enumeration differs from that point.—R.]
1552
[For a full list of
fragments and titles of other Apocryphal Gospels, see Schaff-Herzog, i.
p. 106. Twenty-nine are given, but in some cases the same work
probably appears under two titles.—R.]