flesh and blood."990 It is plain that everywhere he speaks of the second or spiritual birth as
that in which we are made by God, as distinct from the indecency of the first birth, in which
we are on a level with other animals as regards dignity and purity, as we are conceived in
the maternal womb, and are formed, and brought forth. You may observe that in this
matter the dispute between us is not so much about a question of doctrine as of interpreta-
tion. For you think that it is the old or outer or earthy man that is said to have been made
by God; while we apply this to the heavenly man, giving the superiority to the inner or new
man. And our opinion is not rash or groundless, for we have learned it from Christ and
His apostles, who are proved to have been the first in the world who thus taught.
2. Augustin replied: The Apostle Paul certainly uses the expression the inner man for
the spirit of the mind, and the outer man for the body and for this mortal life; but we nowhere
find him making these two different men, but one, which is all made by God, both the inner
and the outer. However, it is made in the image of God only as regards the inner, which,
besides being immaterial, is rational, and is not possessed by the lower animals. God, then,
did not make one man after His own image, and another man not after that image; but the
one man, which includes both the inner and the outer, He made after His own image, not
as regards the possession of a body and of mortal life, but as regards the rational mind with
the power of knowing God, and with the superiority as compared with all irrational creatures
which the possession of reason implies. Faustus allows that the inner man is made by God,
when, as he says, it is renewed in the knowledge of God after the image of Him that created
him. I readily admit this on the apostle’s authority. Why does not Faustus admit on the
same authority that "God has placed the members every one in the body, as it has pleased
Him"?991 Here we learn from the same apostle that God is the framer of the outer man too.
Why does Faustus take only what he thinks to be in his own favor, while he leaves out or
rejects what upsets the follies of the Manichæans? Moreover, in treating of the earthy and
the heavenly man, and making the distinction between the mortal and the immortal, between
that which we are in Adam and that which we shall be in Christ, the apostle quotes the de-
claration of the law regarding the earthy or natural body, referring to the very book and the
very passage where it is written that God made the earthy man too. Speaking of the manner
in which the dead shall rise again, and of the body with which they shall come, after using
the similitude of the seeds of corn, that they are sown bare grain, and that God gives them
a body as it pleases Him, and to every seed his own body,—thus, by the way, overthrowing
the error of the Manichæans, who say that grains and plants, and all roots and shoots, are
created by the race of darkness, and not by God, who, according to them, instead of exerting
power in the production of these objects, is Himself subject to confinement in them,—he
990 Gal. i. 15, 16.
991 1 Cor. xii. 18.
542
Faustus explains the Manichæan denial that man was made by God as applying…