THE AUTHOR’S PREFACE.
My appearing in this public manner on that side of the question, which is defended in
the following sheets, will probably be surprising to many; as it is well known, that Mr.
Stoddard, so great and eminent a divine, and my venerable predecessor in the pastoral office
over the church in Northampton, as well as my own grandfather, publicly and strenuously
appeared in opposition to the doctrine here maintained.
However, I hope it will be not taken amiss that I think as I do, merely because I herein
differ from him, though so much my superior, and one whose name and memory I am under
distinguishing obligations, on every account, to treat with great respect and honour. Especially
may I justly expect, that it will not be charged on me as a crime, that I do not think in every
thing just as he did, since none more than he himself asserted this scriptural and protestant
maxim, that we ought to call no man on earth master, or make the authority of the greatest
and holiest of mere men the ground of our belief of any doctrine in religion. Certainly we
are not obliged to think any man infallible, who himself utterly disclaims infallibility. Very
justly Mr. Stoddard observes in his Appeal to the Learned, p. 97. “All protestants agree, that
there is no infallibility at Rome; and I know nobody else pretends to any, since the apostles’
days.” And he insists, in his preface to his sermon on the same subject, That it argues no
want of a due respect in us to our forefathers, for us to examine their opinions. Some of his
words in that preface contain a good apology for me, and are worthy to be repeated on this
occasion. They are as follows:
“It may possibly be a fault (says Mr. Stoddard) to depart from the ways of our fathers:
but it may also be a virtue, and an eminent act of obedience, to depart from them in some
things. Men are wont to make a great noise, that we are bringing in innovations, and depart
from the old way: but it is beyond me, to find out wherein the iniquity does lie. We may see
cause to alter some practices of our fathers, without despising them, without priding ourselves
in out wisdom, without apostacy, without abusing the advantages God has given us, without
a spirit of compliance with corrupt men, without inclination to superstition, without making
disturbance in the church of God: and there is no reason, that it should be turned as a re-
proach upon us. Surely it is commendable for us to examine the practices of our fathers; we
have no sufficient reason to take practices upon trust from them. Let them have as high a
character as belongs to them; yet we may not look upon their principles as oracles. Nathan
himself missed it in his conjecture about building the house of God. He that believes principles
because they affirm them, makes idols of them. And it would be no humility, but baseness
of spirit, for us to judge ourselves incapable to examine the principles that have been handed
down to us. If we be by any means fit to open the mysteries of the gospel, we are capable to
judge of these matters: and it would ill become us, so to indulge ourselves in case, as to neglect
the examination of received principles. If the practices of our fathers in any particulars were
Preface by the Author.
1740
Preface by the Author.