had either in possession, promise, offer, or some intimation: but a resurrection is made
known only by divine revelation which few comparatively have enjoyed. So that as to such
wicked men as die in lands of darkness, if their resurrection comes at all by Christ, it comes
from him, and to them, only is a curse, and not a blessing; for it never comes to them at all
by any conveyance, grant, promise, or offer, or any thing by which they can claim it, or know
any thing of it, till it comes as an infinite calamity, past all remedy.
205
VIII. In a peculiar manner is there an unreasonable violence used in our author’s explan-
ation of the words sinners and sinned, in the paragraph before us. He says, “These words,
By one man’s disobedience many were made sinners, mean neither more nor less, than that
by one man’s disobedience, the many were made subject to death, by the judicial act of
God.” 96 And he says in the same place, “By death, most certainly, is meant no other than
the death and mortality common to all mankind.” And those words, ver. 12. “For that all
have sinned,” he thus explains, “All men became sinners, as all mankind are brought into a
state of suffering. 97 Here I observe,
1. The main thing, by which he justifies such interpretations, is, that sin, in various in-
stances, is used for suffering, in the Old Testament. 98 To which I reply; though it be true,
that the original word (NOT ENGLISH) signifies both sin, and a sin-offering—and though
this, and some other Hebrew words which signify sin, iniquity, and wickedness, are sometimes
put for the effect or punishment of iniquity, by a metonymy of the cause for the effect—yet
it does not appear, that these words are ever used for suffering, where that suffering is not
a punishment, or a fruit of God’s anger for sin. And therefore none of the instances he
mentions, come up to his purpose. When Lot is commanded to leave Sodom, that he might
not be consumed in the iniquity of the city, meaning in that fire which was the effect and
punishment of the iniquity of the city; this is quite another thing, than if that fire came on
the city in general, as no punishment at all, nor as any fruit of a charge of iniquity, but as a
token of God’s favour to the inhabitants. For according to Dr. T. the death of mankind is
introduced only as a benefit, from a covenant of grace. And especially is this quite another
thing, than if, in the expression used, the iniquity had been ascribed to Lot; and God, instead
of saying, Lest thou be consumed in the iniquity of the city, had said, Lest thou be consumed
in thine iniquity, or, Lest thou sin, or be made a sinner. Whereas the expression is such, as
expressly removes the iniquity spoken of from Lot, and fixes it on the city. The place cited
by our author in Jer. li. is exactly parallel. And as to what Abimelech says to Abraham, “What
have I offended thee, that thou hast brought on me, and on my kingdom, a great sin?” 99 It
96 Page 30.
97 Page 54, and elsewhere.
98 Page 34.
99 Gen. xx. 9.
1101
SECTION I. Remarks on Dr. Taylor's way of explaining this text.