375
thus ignorant, accepted the testimony of the judges who decided the case as more worthy
of credit than that of those by whom the accusation was brought. No man deserves to be
blamed for the crime of another; what, then, has the whole world to do with the sin which
some one in Africa may have committed? No man deserves to be blamed for a crime about
which he knows nothing; and how could the whole world possibly know the crime in this
case, whether the judges or the party condemned were guilty? Ye who have understanding,
judge what I say. Here is the justice of heretics: the party of Donatus condemns the whole
world unheard, because the whole world does not condemn a crime unknown. But for the
world, truly, it suffices to have the promises of God, and to see fulfilled in itself what
prophets predicted so long ago, and to recognise the Church by means of the same Scriptures
by which Christ her King is recognised. For as in them are foretold concerning Christ the
things which we read in gospel history to have been fulfilled in Him, so also in them have
been foretold concerning the Church the things which we now behold fulfilled in the world.
5. Possibly some thinking people might be disturbed by what they are accustomed to
say regarding baptism, viz. that it is the true baptism of Christ only when it is administered
by a righteous man, were it not that on this subject the Christian world holds what is most
manifestly evangelical truth as taught in the words of John: “He that sent me to baptize with
water, the same said unto me, Upon whom thou shalt see the Spirit descending, and remain-
ing on him, the same is he which baptizeth with the Holy Ghost.”2118 Wherefore the Church
calmly declines to place her hope in man, lest she fall under the curse pronounced in
Scripture, “Cursed be the man that trusteth in man,”2119 but places her hope in Christ, who
so took upon Him the form of a servant as not to lose the form of God, of whom it is said,
“The same is He which baptizeth.” Therefore, whoever the man be, and whatever office he
bear who administers the ordinance, it is not he who baptizes,—that is the work of Him
upon whom the dove descended. So great is the absurdity in which the Donatists are involved
in consequence of these foolish opinions, that they can find no escape from it. For when
they admit the validity and reality of baptism when one of their sect baptizes who is a guilty
man, but whose guilt is concealed, we ask them, Who baptizes in this case? and they can
only answer, God; for they cannot affirm that a man guilty of sin (say of adultery) can
sanctify any one. If, then, when baptism is administered by a man known to be righteous,
he sanctifies the person baptized; but when it is administered by a wicked man, whose
wickedness is hidden, it is not he, but God, who sanctifies. Those who are baptized ought
to wish to be baptized rather by men who are secretly bad than by men manifestly good, for
God sanctifies much more effectually than any righteous man can do. If it be palpably absurd
that one about to be baptized ought to wish to be baptized by a hypocritical adulterer rather
2118 John i. 33.
2119 Jer. xvii. 5.
832
To Festus