Festus, a government official and a landed proprietor apparently in Hippo, had written
a letter urging a return of the Donatists to the mother Church. It bore little fruit, and he
asks Augustin first to instruct him and also to give him a tractate for general use. Augustin,
c. 406. [Ep. lxxxix.], enforces the duty of perseverance in the civil reclamation of the
Donatists; their claim of persecution as a note attesting them to be the true people of God
is folly, because it is not the mere suffering but the cause for which one suffers that makes
a martyr. He exhorts him to read the archives and see how the schismatics initiated the
appeal to the secular power, and how all things that have befallen them through that arm
would have been the just fate of the Cæcilianists, had the Donatist course been approved.
Besides, why this unjust treatment of the Church universal in condemning it unheard, and
rebaptizing its members, who have done them no wrong? The theory that baptism alone
is valid when administered by the just, is putting a trust in man which the Scriptures con-
demn; the sacrament is not man’s but Christ’s; further, one would prefer to be baptized by
a bad man, for then he would receive grace from Christ directly, according to their subter-
fuge. He is vexed with their active and passive opposition; the mother has to correct, although
her obstinate child may not like it. They aver that the Catholics accept them without requir-
ing any change in them, but the change required is great, no less a one than from error to
truth. The bishop proposes as a substitute for Festus’s plan, the sending of an authorized
messenger secretly to himself, and they would devise together a method for the correction
of the Donatists.
In the second sermon on Ps. cii. (ci.) preached about this time, when enlarging upon
the unity he ridicules the Donatist assertion that the Church which was among all the nations
had perished, as the impudent voice of those who are not in it declares. So is their affirmation
that Scripture prophecies about the spread of the kingdom have been fulfilled; all nations
have believed, but this diffused communion apostatized and perished. He rebukes the
conceit that the Lord’s saying, I am with you, even to the end of the world, was designed for
them alone, the Lord foreseeing that the party of Donatus would be in the earth. If emperors
have propounded laws against heretics, it is a part of the predictions which foretold how
kings would serve the Lord. Thence he expands the notes of universality and perpetuity.
Cresconius, a layman and philologist, read Augustin’s first book in answer to Petilian,
and wrote a reply, which, however, was circulated among the Donatists only. Augustin at
last secured a copy, and wrote (406 A.D., some say as late as 409) Contra Cresconium
Grammaticum Partis Donati, libri IV. Three of these books controvert the arguments of
Cresconius; part of the third and the fourth entire is a detailed polemic history of the Max-
imian schism.
In Book I. he alludes to the occasion of the writing, and hesitates between being regarded
as contumelious if he declined an answer, and arrogant, should he reply. Cresconius had
attacked eloquence, which Augustin defends as simply the art of speaking, and as not to be
664
An Analysis of Augustin’s Writings Against the Donatists.