VII.—The Breach with Gregory of Nazianzus.
Cappadocia, it has been seen, had been divided into two provinces, and of one of these
Tyana had been constituted the chief town. Anthimus, bishop of Tyana, now contended
that an ecclesiastical partition should follow the civil, and that Tyana should enjoy parallel
metropolitan privileges to those of Cæsarea. To this claim Basil determined to offer an
uncompromising resistance, and summoned Gregory of Nazianzus to his side. Gregory
replied in friendly and complimentary terms,187 and pointed out that Basil’s friendship for
Eustathius of Sebaste was a cause of suspicion in the Church. At the same time he placed
himself at the archbishop’s disposal. The friends started together with a train of slaves and
mules to collect the produce of the monastery of St. Orestes, in Cappadocia Secunda, which
was the property of the see of Cæsarea. Anthimus blocked the defiles with his retainers and
in the vicinity of Sasima188 there was an unseemly struggle between the domestics of the
two prelates.189 The friends proceeded to Nazianzus, and there, with imperious inconsid-
erateness, Basil insisted upon nominating Gregory to one of the bishoprics which he was
founding in order to strengthen his position against Anthimus.190 For Gregory, the
brother, Nyssa was selected, a town on the Halys, about a hundred miles distant from
Cæsarea, so obscure that Eusebius of Samosata remonstrated with Basil on the unreason-
ableness of forcing such a man to undertake the episcopate of such a place.191 For Gregory,
the friend, a similar fate was ordered. The spot chosen was Sasima, a townlet commanding
the scene of the recent fray.192 It was an insignificant place at the bifurcation of the road
187 Greg. Naz., Ep. xlvii.
188 cf. Maran, Vit. Bas. xxiii. 4.
189 Greg. Naz., Or. xliii. 58, and Ep. xlviii. Bas., Epp. lxxiv., lxxv., lxxvi.
190 It has been debated whether the odium theologicum was here mixed up with the odium ecclesiasticum.
Gregory (Orat. xliii. 58) represents Anthimus as defending his seizure of the metropolitan revenues on the ground
that it was wrong δασμοφορειν κακοδόξοις, to pay tribute to men of evil opinions, and LeClerc (Bibl. Univer.
xviii. p. 60) has condemned Anthimus as an Arian. He was undoubtedly Αρή& 187·ος (Greg. Naz., Ep. xlviii.),
a devotee of Ares, as he shewed in the skirmish by Sasima; but there is no reason to suppose him to have been
Αρειανός, or Arian. He probably looked askance at the orthodoxy of Basil. Basil would never have called him
ὁμόψυχος (Ep. ccx. 5) if he had been unsound on the incarnation. cf. Baronius, Act. Sanc. Maj. ii. p. 394.
191 Ep. xcviii., but see note, p. 182, on the doubt as to this allusion.
192 Greg. Naz., with grim humour, objects to be sent to Sasima to fight for Basil’s supply of sucking pigs and
poultry from St. Orestes. Ep. xlviii.
The Breach with Gregory of Nazianzus.
36
The Breach with Gregory of Nazianzus.