its affairs. Yet did not each gather disciples to follow his own sect? Indeed, in the conspicu-
ous and well-known porch, in gymnasia, in gardens, in places public and private, they openly
strove in bands each for his own opinion, some asserting there was one world, others innu-
merable worlds; some that this world had a beginning, others that it had not; some that it
would perish, others that it would exist always; some that it was governed by the divine
mind, others by chance and accident; some that souls are immortal, others that they are
mortal,—and of those who asserted their immortality, some said they transmigrated through
beasts, others that it was by no means so; while of those who asserted their mortality, some
said they perished immediately after the body, others that they survived either a little while
or a longer time, but not always; some fixing supreme good in the body, some in the mind,
some in both; others adding to the mind and body external good things; some thinking that
the bodily senses ought to be trusted always, some not always, others never. Now what
people, senate, power, or public dignity of the impious city has ever taken care to judge
between all these and other well-nigh innumerable dissensions of the philosophers, approving
and accepting some, and disapproving and rejecting others? Has it not held in its bosom
at random, without any judgment, and confusedly, so many controversies of men at variance,
not about fields, houses, or anything of a pecuniary nature, but about those things which
make life either miserable or happy? Even if some true things were said in it, yet falsehoods
were uttered with the same licence; so that such a city has not amiss received the title of the
mystic Babylon. For Babylon means confusion, as we remember we have already explained.
Nor does it matter to the devil, its king, how they wrangle among themselves in contradictory
errors, since all alike deservedly belong to him on account of their great and varied impiety.
But that nation, that people, that city, that republic, these Israelites, to whom the oracles
of God were entrusted, by no means confounded with similar licence false prophets with
the true prophets; but, agreeing together, and differing in nothing, acknowledged and upheld
the authentic authors of their sacred books. These were their philosophers, these were their
sages, divines, prophets, and teachers of probity and piety. Whoever was wise and lived
according to them was wise and lived not according to men, but according to God who hath
spoken by them. If sacrilege is forbidden there, God hath forbidden it. If it is said, “Honor
thy father and thy mother,”1215 God hath commanded it. If it is said, “Thou shall not
commit adultery, Thou shall not kill, Thou shall not steal,”1216 and other similar command-
ments, not human lips but the divine oracles have enounced them. Whatever truth certain
philosophers, amid their false opinions, were able to see, and strove by laborious discussions
to persuade men of,—such as that God had made this world, and Himself most providently
governs it, or of the nobility of the virtues, of the love of country, of fidelity in friendship,
1215 Ex. xx. 12.
1216 Ex. xx. 13–15, the order as in Mark x. 19.
873
About the Discord of Philosophic Opinion, and the Concord of the Scriptures…