we pluck up their sophistries by the root. Let them, therefore, desist from bringing against
us objections which are of equal force against every sect, and against religion of every name.
For since, as they admit, the ages of the world do not roll on under the dominion of chance,
but are controlled by divine Providence, what may be fitting and expedient in each successive
age transcends the range of human understanding, and is determined by the same wisdom
by which Providence cares for the universe.
14. For if they assert that the reason why the doctrine of Pythagoras has not prevailed
always and universally is, that Pythagoras was but a man, and had not power to secure this,
can they also affirm that in the age and in the countries in which his philosophy flourished,
all who had the opportunity of hearing him were found willing to believe and follow him?
And therefore it is the more certain that, if Pythagoras had possessed the power of publishing
his doctrines where he pleased and when he pleased, and if he had also possessed along with
that power a perfect foreknowledge of events, he would have presented himself only at those
places and times in which he foreknew that men would believe his teaching. Wherefore,
since they do not object to Christ on the ground of His doctrine not being universally em-
418
braced,—for they feel that this would be a futile objection if alleged either against the
teaching of philosophers or against the majesty of their own gods,—what answer, I ask,
could they make, if, leaving out of view that depth of the wisdom and knowledge of God
within which it may be that some other divine purpose lies much more deeply hidden, and
without prejudging the other reasons possibly existing, which are fit subjects for patient
study by the wise, we confine ourselves, for the sake of brevity in this discussion, to the
statement of this one position, that it pleased Christ to appoint the time in which He would
appear and the persons among whom His doctrine was to be proclaimed, according to His
knowledge of the times and places in which men would believe on Him?2341 For He foreknew,
2341 Augustin, having been informed by Hilary (Ep. 219) that this passage was quoted by Semipelagians in
defence of their error, made the following remark on it in his work De Prædestinatione Sanctorum, c. ix.: “Do
you not observe that my design in this sentence was, without excluding the secret counsel of God and any other
causes, to say, in reference to Christ’s foreknowledge, what seemed sufficient to reduce to silence the unbelief
of the Pagans by whom the objection had been raised? For what is more certain than this, that Christ foreknew
who would believe in Him, and in what time and place they would live? But I did not deem it necessary, in that
connection, to investigate and discuss the question as to this faith in Christ preached to them, whether they
would have it of themselves or would receive it from God—in other words, whether God merely foreknew, or
also predestinated them. The sentence, therefore, ‘that it pleased Christ to appoint the time in which He would
appear, and the persons among whom His doctrine was to be proclaimed, according to His knowledge of the
times and places in which men would believe in Him,’ might have been put thus: that it pleased Christ to appoint
the time in which He would appear, and the persons among whom His doctrine was to be proclaimed, according
to His knowledge of the times and places in which those would be found who had been chosen in Him before
the foundation of the world.”
913
To Deogratias