Translator’s Preface.
————————————
The
history
of St. Augustin’s treatise on the Trinity, as gathered by
Tillemont and others from his own allusions to it, may be briefly
given. It is placed by him in his
Retractations
among the
works written (which in the present case, it appears, must mean
begun) in
A.D.
400. In letters of
A.D.
410, 414, and at the end of
A.D.
415 (
Ad Consentium
, Ep. 120, and two
Ad Evodium
, Epp. 162, 169), it is referred to as still
unfinished and unpublished. But a letter of
A.D.
412 (
Ad Marcellinum
, Ep. 143) intimates that
friends were at that time importuning him, although without
success, to complete and publish it. And the letter to Aurelius,
which was sent to that bishop with the treatise itself when
actually completed, informs us that a portion of it, while it was
still unrevised and incomplete, was in fact surreptitiously made
public,—a proceeding which the letters above cited postpone
apparently until at least after
A.D.
415.
It was certainly still in hand in
A.D.
416, inasmuch as in Book XIII. a quotation occurs from the 12th
Book of the
De Civitate Dei
; and another quotation in Book
XV., from the 90th lecture on St. John, indicates most probably a
date of at least a year later,
viz
.
A.D.
417. The
Retractations
, which refer to it, are
usually dated not later than
A.D.
428. The
letter to Bishop Aurelius also informs us that the work was many
years in progress, and was begun in St. Augustin’s early manhood,
and finished in his old age. We may infer from this evidence that
it was written by him between
A.D.
400,
when he was forty-six years old, and had been Bishop of Hippo about
four years, and
A.D.
428 at the latest;
but probably it was published ten or twelve years before this date.
He writes of it, indeed, himself, as if the “
nonum prematur in
annum
” very inadequately represented the amount of deliberate
and patient thought which a subject so profound and so sacred
demanded, and which he had striven to give to it; and as if, even
at the very last, he shrank from publishing his work, and was only
driven to do so in order to remedy the mischief of its partial and
unauthorized publication.
His motive for writing on the
subject may be learned from the treatise itself. It was not
directed against any individual antagonist, or occasioned by any
particular controversial emergency. In fact, his labors upon it
were, he says, continually interrupted by the distraction of such
controversies. Certain ingenious and subtle theories respecting
types or resemblances of the Holy Trinity, traceable in human
nature as being the image of God, seemed to him to supply, not
indeed a logical proof, but a strong rational presumption, of the
truth of the doctrine itself; and thus to make it incumbent upon
him to expound and unfold them in order to meet rationalizing
objectors upon (so to say) their own ground. He is careful not to
deal with these analogies or images as if they either constituted a
purely argumentative proof or exhausted the full meaning of the
doctrine, upon both which assumptions such speculations have at all
times been the fruitful parent both of presumptious theorizing and
of grievous heresy. But he nevertheless employs them more
affirmatively than would perhaps have been the case. While modern
theologians would argue negatively, from the triplicity of
independent faculties,—united, nevertheless, in the unity of a
single human person,—that any presumption of reason against the
Trinity of persons in the Godhead is thereby, if not removed, at
least materially and enormously lessened, St. Augustin seems to
argue positively from analogous grounds, as though they constituted
a direct intimation of the doctrine itself. But he takes especial
pains, at the same time, to dwell upon the incapacity of human
thought to fathom the depths of the nature of God; and he carefully
prefaces his reasonings by a statement of the Scripture evidence of
the catholic doctrine as a matter of faith and not of reason, and
by an explanation of difficult texts upon the subject. One of the
most valuable portions, indeed, of the treatise is the eloquent and
profound exposition given in this part of it of the rule of
interpretation to be applied to Scripture language respecting the
person of our Lord. It should be noticed, however, that a large
proportion of St. Augustin’s scriptural exege
sis is
founded upon a close verbal exposition of the old Latin version,
and is frequently not borne out by the original text. And the rule
followed in rendering Scripture texts in the present translation
has been, accordingly, wherever the argument in the context rests
upon the variations of the old Latin, there to translate the words
as St. Augustin gives them, while adhering otherwise to the
language of the authorized English version. The reader’s
attention may allowably be drawn to the language of Book V. c.x.,
and to its close resemblance to some of the most remarkable phrases
of the Athanasian Creed, and again to the striking passage
respecting miracles in Book III. c.v., and to that upon the nature
of God at the beginning of Book V.; the last named of which seems
to have suggested one of the profoundest passages in the
profoundest of Dr. Newman’s
University Sermons
(p. 353,
ed. 1843). It may be added, that the writings of the Greek Fathers
on the subject were, if not wholly unknown, yet unfamiliar to
Augustin, who quotes directly only the Latin work of Hilary of
Poictiers.
It remains to say, that the
translation here printed was made about four years since by a
friend of the writer of this preface, and that the latter’s share
in the work has been that of thoroughly revising and correcting it,
and of seeing it through the press. He is therefore answerable for
the work as now published.
A. W.
Haddan
.
Nov. 5, 1872.
————————————
In the
Retractations
(ii.
15) Augustin speaks of this work in the following
terms:—
“I spent some years in writing
fifteen books concerning the Trinity, which is God. When, however,
I had not yet finished the thirteenth Book, and some who were
exceedingly anxious to have the work were kept waiting longer than
they could bear, it was stolen from me in a less correct state than
it either could or would have been had it appeared when I intended.
And as soon as I discovered this, having other copies of it, I had
determined at first not to publish it myself, but to mention what
had happened in the matter in some other work; but at the urgent
request of brethren, whom I could not refuse, I corrected it as
much as I thought fit, and finished and published it, with the
addition, at the beginning, of a letter that I had written to the
venerable Aurelius, Bishop of Carthage, in which I set forth, in
the way of prologue, what had happened, what I had intended to do
of myself, and what love of my brethren had forced me to
do.”
The letter to which he here alludes
is the following:—
“To the most blessed Lord, whom
he reveres with most sincere love, to his holy brother and
fellow-priest, Pope Aurelius, Augustin sends health in the
Lord.
“I began as a very young man, and
have published in my old age, some books concerning the Trinity,
who is the supreme and true God. I had in truth laid the work
aside, upon discovering that it had been prematurely, or rather
surreptitiously, stolen from me before I had completed it, and
before I had revised and put the finishing touches to it, as had
been my intention. For I had not designed to publish the Books one
by one, but all together, inasmuch as the progress of the inquiry
led me to add the later ones to those which precede them. When,
therefore, these people had hindered the fulfillment of my purpose
(in that some of them had obtained access to the work before I
intended), I had given over dictating it, with the idea of making
my complaint public in some other work that I might write, in order
that whoso could might know that the Books had not been published
by myself, but had been taken away from my possession before they
were in my own judgment fit for publication. Compelled, however, by
the eager demands of many of my brethren, and above all by your
command, I have taken the pains, by God’s help, to complete the
work, laborious as it is; and as now corrected (not as I wished,
but as I could, lest the Books should differ very widely from those
which had surreptitiously got into people’s hands), I have sent
them to your Reverence by my very dear son and fellow-deacon, and
have allowed them to be heard, copied, and read by every one that
pleases. Doubtless, if I could have fulfilled my original
intention, although they would have contained the same sentiments,
they would have been worked out much more thoroughly and clearly,
so far as the difficulty of unfolding so profound a subject, and so
far, too, as my own powers, might have allowed. There are some
persons, however, who have the first four, or rather five, Books
without the prefaces, and the twelfth with no small part of its
later chapters omitted. But these, if they please and can, will
amend the whole, if they become acquainted with the present
edition. At any rate, I have to request that you will order this
letter to be prefixed separately, but at the beginning of the
Books. Farewell. Pray for me.”