Canon IV.
Let
those who truly and
sincerely lead the monastic life be counted worthy of becoming honour;
but, forasmuch as certain persons using the pretext of monasticism
bring confusion both upon the churches and into political affairs by
going about promiscuously in the cities, and at the same time seeking
to establish Monasteries for themselves; it is decreed that no one
anywhere build or found a monastery or oratory contrary to the will of
the bishop of the city; and that the monks in every city and district
shall be subject to the bishop, and embrace a quiet course of life, and
give themselves only to fasting and prayer, remaining permanently in
the places in which they were set apart; and they shall meddle neither
in ecclesiastical nor in secular affairs, nor leave their own
monasteries to take part in such; unless, indeed, they should at any
time through urgent necessity be appointed thereto by the bishop of the
city. And no slave shall be received into any monastery to become
a monk against the will of his master. And if any one shall
transgress this our judgment, we have decreed that he shall be
excommunicated, that the name of God be not blasphemed. But the
bishop of the city must make the needful provision for the
monasteries.
Notes.
Ancient Epitome of Canon IV.
Domestic oratories and monasteries are not to be erected
contrary to the judgment of the bishop. Every monk must be
subject to his bishop, and must not leave his house except at his
suggestion. A slave, however, can not enter the monastic life
without the consent of his master.
Hefele.
Like the previous canon, this one was brought forward by
the Emperor Marcian in the sixth session, and then as number one, and
the synod accepted the Emperor’s proposed canon almost
verbally. Occasion for this canon seems to have been given by
monks of Eutychian tendencies, and especially by the Syrian Barsumas,
as appears from the fourth session. He and his monks had, as
Eutychians, withdrawn themselves from the jurisdiction of their
bishops, whom they suspected of Nestorianism.
Bright.
Here observe (1) the definite assertion of episcopal
authority over monks, as it is repeated for greater clearness in the
last words of the canon, which are not found in Marcian’s draft,
“It is the duty of the bishop of the city to make due provision
for the monasteries,” and compare canons 8, 24. Isidore
says that the bishop must “keep an eye on the negligences of
monks” (
Epist
., i. 149). The Western Church followed
in this track (see Council of Agde, canon xxvii., that “no new
monastery is to be founded without the bishop’s approval,”
and Ist of Orleans, canon xix., “Let abbots be under the
bishop’s
power,” and
also Vth of Paris, canon xij., Mansi, viii., 329, 354, 542, etc.),
until a reaction set in against the oppressiveness of bishops, was
encouraged by Gregory the Great (
Epist
., i. 12; ii. 41), the
IV
th
Council of Toledo (canon li.),
and the English Council of Hertford (canon iij., Bede, iv. 5, and
Bright’s
Chapters of Early Engl. Ch. Hist
., p. 244), and
culminated in the system of monastic exemptions, of which Monte
Cassino, St. Martin’s of Tours, Fulda, Westminster, Battle (see
Freeman,
Norm. Conquest
, iv. 409), and St. Alban’s were
eminent instances.
This canon, cut up and mutilated, is found in the
Corpus Juris Canonici
, Gratian’s
Decretum
, Pars
II., Causa XVI., Quæst. L, can. xij., and Causa XVIII.,
Quæst. II., Canon X.
I have followed the reading of the
Prisca
, and of
Dionysius, of Routh, and of Balsamon, “they were set
apart,” i.e. (as Balsamon explains) where they received the
monastic tonsure. This reading substitutes
ἀπετάξαντο
for
ἐπετάξαντο
, which would mean “over which they had been put in
authority,” or possibly (as Johnson) “where they are
appointed,” or as Hammond, “in which they have been
settled.” Isidore reads “
ordinati
sunt
.”