1947 Hippolytus (mentioned above in chap. 20) was one of the most learned men and celebrated writers of
his age, and yet his personal history is involved in the deepest obscurity. The earliest mention of him is by Euse-
bius in this passage and in chap. 20, above. But Eusebius tells us there only that he was a bishop of “some other
church” (ἑτέρας που ἐκκλησίας), and Jerome (de vir. ill. c. 61) says that he was a bishop of some church whose
name he did not know (Hippolytus, cujusdam Ecclesiæ episcopus, nomen quippe urbis scire non potui). In the
East, from the fourth century on, Hippolytus was commonly called bishop of Rome, but the Western tradition
makes him simply a presbyter. The late tradition that he was bishop of Portus Romanus is quite worthless. We
learn from his Philosophumena, or Refutation of Heresies, that he was active in Rome in the time of Zephyrinus
and Callistus; but what is significant is the fact that he never recognizes Callistus as bishop of Rome, but always
treats him as the head of a school opposed to the orthodox Church. This has given scholars the clue for recon-
ciling the conflicting traditions about his position and his church. It seems probable that he was a presbyter of
the church of Rome, and was at the head of a party which did not recognize Callistus as lawful bishop, but set
Hippolytus up as opposition bishop. This explains why Hippolytus calls himself a bishop, and at the same time
recognizes neither Callistus nor any one else as bishop of Rome. The Western Church therefore preserved the
tradition of Hippolytus only as a presbyter, while in the Orient, where Hippolytus was known only through his
works, the tradition that he was a bishop (a fact directly stated in those works; see the preface to his Philo-
sophumena) always prevailed; and since he was known to have resided in Rome, that city was made by tradition
his see. The schism, which has left no trace in the writings either of the Western or Eastern Church, cannot have
been a serious one. Doubtless Callistus had the support of by far the larger part of the Church, and the opposition
of Hippolytus never amounted to more than talk, and was never strong enough to enlist, or perhaps even attempt
to enlist, the support of foreign bishops. Callistus and the body of the Church could afford to leave it unnoticed;
and after Callistus’ death Hippolytus undoubtedly returned to the Church and was gladly received, and the
memory of his brief schism entirely effaced, while the knowledge of his orthodoxy, and of his great services to
the Church as a theologian and a writer, kept his name in high repute with subsequent generations. A Latin
translation of a Chronicle written by Hippolytus is extant, and the last event recorded in it is the death of the
Emperor Alexander, which took place early in the year 235. The Liberian catalogue, in an entry which Lipsius
(Chron. d. röm. Bischöfe, p. 194) pronounces critically indisputable, records that, in the year 235, the bishop
Pontianus and the presbyter Hippolytus were transported as exiles to the island of Sardinia. There is little doubt
that this is the Hippolytus with whom we are concerned, and it is highly probable that both he and Pontianus
died in the mines there, and thus gained the title of martyrs; for not only is the account of Hippolytus’ martyrdom
given by Prudentius in the fifth century not reliable, but also in the depositio martyrum of the Liberian catalogue
the bodies of Pontianus and Hippolytus are said to have been buried in Rome on the same day; and it is therefore
natural to think that Hippolytus’ body was brought from Sardinia, as we know Pontianus’ was. The character
of Hippolytus, as revealed to us in the Philosophumena, is that of a strictly, even rigidly, moral man, of a purit-
anic disposition, who believed in drawing the reins very tight, and allowing to the members of the Christian
Church no license. He was in this directly opposed to Callistus, who was a lax disciplinarian, and favored the
readmission to the Church even of the worst offenders upon evidence of repentance and suitable penance (see
the previous chapter, note 3). We are reminded greatly of Tertullian and of Novatian in studying Hippolytus’
character. He was, moreover, strictly orthodox and bitterly opposed to what he considered the patripassianism
669
The Works of Hippolytus which have reached us.