316 ON THE TRINITY. [BOOK XIII.
Por certainly, if it is in the pleasure of the body, he is blessed
who enjoys the pleasure of the body ; if in goodness of mind,
he has it who enjoys this; if in both, he who enjoys both.
When, therefore, one says, to live blessedly is to enjoy the
pleasure of the body ; but another, to live blessedly is to enjoy
goodness of mind ; is it not, that either both know, or both do
not know, what a blessed life is ? How, then, do both love it, if
no one can love what he does not know ? Or is that perhaps
false which we have assumed to be most true and most certain,
viz. that all men will to live blessedly ? For if to live bless-
edly is, for argument's sake, to live according to goodness of
mind, how does he will to live blessedly who does not will
this ? Should we not say more truly, That man does not will
to live blessedly, because he does not wish to live according to
goodness, which alone is to live blessedly ? Therefore all men
do not will to live blessedly ; on the contrary, few wish it ; if
to live blessedly is nothing else but to live according to good-
ness of mind, which many do not will to do. Shall we, then,
hold that to be false of which the Academic Cicero himself
did not doubt (alfhough Academics doubt everything), who,
when he wanted in the dialogue Hortensius to find some
certain thing, of which no one doubted, from which to start
his argument, says. We certainly all will to be blessed 1 Far
be it from me to say this is false. But what then ? Are we
to say that, although there is no other way of living blessedly
than living according to goodness ofmind, yet even he who does
not will this, wills to live blessedly ? This, indeed, seems too
absurd. For it is much as if we should say. Even he who does
not will to live blessedly, wills to live blessedly. Who could
listen to, who could endure, such a contradiction ? And yet
necessity thrusts us into this strait, if it is both true that all
will to live blessedly, and yet all do not will to live in that
way in which alone one can live blessedly.
Chap. v.—Of the same thing.
8. Or is, perhaps, the deliverance from our difficulties to be
found in this, that, since we have said that every one places
his idea of a blessed life in that which has most pleased him,
as pleasure pleased Epicurus, and goodness Zeno, and some-
thing else pleased other people, we say that to live blessedly