divers of Mr. Edwards’s adherents, and some severe censures of them all indiscriminately;
all of which, if not wholly false and groundless, yet were altogether unnecessary, and therefore
highly criminal. Indeed I am fully convinced that the whole of that composure, excepting
the small part of it relating to the expediency of Mr. Edwards’s resettlement at Northampton,
was totally unchristian,—a scandalous, abusive, injurious libel against Mr. Edwards and his
particular friends, especially the former, and highly provoking and detestable in the sight
of God; for which I am heartily sorry and ashamed; and pray I may remember it, with deep
abasement and penitence, all my days.” After this remonstrance of the church had been
read before the council, they immediately invited the committee, by whom it was signed, to
come forward, and prove the numerous allegations and insinuations which it contained;
but they refused to appear and support any of their charges, or so much as to give the gen-
cxxv
tlemen of the council any opportunity to confer with them, about the affair depending,
though it was diligently sought; and though, by presenting the remonstrance, they had vir-
tually given the council jurisdiction, as to the charges it contained, yet they utterly refused
to acknowledge them to be an ecclesiastical council. The council then invited the church, as
a body, to a friendly conference, to see if some measures could not be devised for the removal
of the difficulties, in which the ecclesiastical affairs of the town were involved; but although
this was earnestly and repeatedly moved for, on the part of the council, it was repeatedly
and finally denied on the part of the church.
The council having heard what Mr. Edwards, and those who adhered to him, had to
say, advised, agreeably to the judgment of Mr. Edwards, that he should leave Northampton,
and accept of the invitations which he had received, to take charge of the Indian mission,
as well as of the church and congregation, at Stockbridge; of which a more particular account
will be given.
As a proper close to this melancholy story, and to confirm and illustrate what has been
related, the following letter from Joseph Hawley, Esq. to the Rev. Mr. Hall, of Sutton, pub-
lished in a weekly newspaper in Boston, May 9, 1760, is here inserted. This gentleman was
a near kinsman of Mr. Edwards, 38 though his active opponent; he was a lawyer of distin-
guished talents and eloquence.
“To the Rev. Mr. Hall, of Sutton.
Northampton, May 9, 1760.
rev. sir,
I have often wished that every member of the two ecclesiastical councils, that formerly
sat in Northampton, upon the unhappy differences, between our former most worthy and
reverend pastor, Mr. Jonathan Edwards, and the church here, whereof you were a member;
38 The father of Mr. Hawley married Rebekah, the fifth daughter of the Rev. Mr. Stoddard, the sister of Mr.
Edwards’s mother.
257
CHAPTER XVIII. Letter to Mr. M'Cullock—to Mr. Erskine. Account of the troubles…