317
Those who deny that the XV. Anathemas were adopted by the Fifth Synod agree in as-
signing them to the “Home Synod,” that is a Synod at Constantinople of the bishops subject
to it, in a.d. 543. Hefele takes this view and advocates it with much cogency, but confesses
frankly, “We certainly possess no strong and decisive proof that the fifteen anathematisms
belong to the Constantinopolitan synod of the year 543; but some probable grounds for the
opinion may be adduced.”313 This appears to be a somewhat weak statement with which
to overthrow so much evidence as there can be produced for the opposite view. For the
traditional view the English reader will find a complete defence in E. B. Pusey, What is of
Faith with regard to Eternal Punishment?
Before closing it will be well to call the attention of the reader to these words now found
in the acts as we have them:
“And we found that many others had been anathematised after death, also even Origen;
and if any one were to go back to the times of Theophilus of blessed memory or further he
would have found him anathematised after death; which also now your holiness and Vigilius,
the most religious Pope of Old Rome has done in his case.”314 It would seem that this
cannot possibly refer to anything else than a condemnation of Origen by the Fifth Ecumen-
ical Synod, and so strongly is Vincenzi, Origen’s defender, impressed with this that he declares
the passage to have been tampered with. But even if these anathemas were adopted at the
Home Synod before the meeting of the Fifth Ecumenical, it is clear that by including his
name among those of the heretics in the XIth Canon, it practically ratified and made its own
the action of that Synod.
The reader will be glad to know Harnack’s judgment in this matter. Writing of the Fifth
Council, he says: “It condemned Origen, as Justinian desired; it condemned the Three
Chapters and consequently the Antiochene theology, as Justinian desired,” etc., and in a
foot-note he explains that he agrees with “Noris, the Ballerini, Möller (R. Encykl., xi., p. 113)
and Loofs (pp. 287, 291) as against Hefele and Vincenzi.”315 A few pages before, he speaks
of this last author’s book as “a big work which falsifies history to justify the theses of Halloix,
to rehabilitate Origen and Vigilius, and on the other hand to ‘remodel’ the Council and
partly to bring it into contempt.”316 Further on he says: “The fifteen anathemas against
Origen, on which his condemnation at the council was based, contained the following
points.…Since the ‘Three Chapters’ were condemned at the same time, Origen and Theodore
were both got rid of.…Origen’s doctrines of the consummation, and of spirits and matter
313 Hefele. Hist. Councils, Vol. IV., p. 223.
314 Speech of Ascidas in the V. Session.
315 Harnack. Hist. of Dogma, Vol. IV., n. 249 (Eng. Trans.).
316 Ibid., p. 245, note 2.
575
Excursus on the XV. Anathemas Against Origen.