16. If Auxentius appeals to a synod, in order to discuss points concerning the faith (al-
though it is not necessary that so many Bishops should be troubled for the sake of one man,
who, even if he were an angel from heaven, ought not to be preferred to the peace of the
Church), when I hear that a synod is gathering, I, too, will not be wanting. Repeal, then, the
law if you wish for a disputation.
17. I would have come, O Emperor, to your consistory, and have made these remarks
in your presence, if either the Bishops or the people had allowed me, but they said that
matters concerning the faith ought to be treated in the church, in presence of the people.
18. And I wish, O Emperor, that you had not given sentence that I should go into ban-
ishment whither I would. I went out daily. No one guarded me. You ought to have appointed
me a place wherever you would, for I offered myself for anything. But now the clergy say
429
to me, “There is not much difference whether you voluntarily leave the altar of Christ or
betray it, for if you leave it you will betray it.”
19. And I wish it were clearly certain to me that the Church would by no means be given
over to the Arians. I would then willingly offer myself to the will of your piety. But if I only
am guilty of disturbance, why is there a command to invade all other churches? I would it
were established that no one should trouble the churches, and then I could wish that whatever
sentence seems good should be pronounced concerning me.
20. Vouchsafe, then, O Emperor, to accept the reason for which I could not come to the
consistory. I have never learned to appear in the consistory except on your behalf,57 and I
am not able to dispute within the palace, who neither know nor wish to know the secrets of
the palace.
21. I, Ambrose, Bishop, offer this memorial to the most gracious Emperor, and most
blessed Augustus Valentinian.
57 This refers modestly to the legations undertaken by St. Ambrose on two separate occasions to Maximus,
when the Empress Justina feared for the safety of herself and Valentinian. In his first mission, a.d. 383, he had
at great personal risk induced Maximus not to invade Italy, but to leave Valentinian in peaceful possession of a
share of the empire. In his second embassy, a.d. 387, he was less successful, as Maximus had determined on in-
vading Italy; so that Justina and Valentinian escaped to the East, seeking the protection of Theodosius, who took
their part, and defeated Maximus and put him to death at Aquileia, a.d. 388.
916
Letter XXI: To Valentinian II., Declining Challenge of Auxentius.