Chapter
XVI
.—
Introductory to
Proverbs viii.
22
,
that the Son is not a Creature
.
Arian formula, a creature but
not as one of the creatures; but each creature is unlike all other
creatures; and no creature can create. The Word then differs from all
creatures in that in which they, though otherwise differing, all agree
together, as creatures; viz. in being an efficient cause; in being the
one medium or instrumental agent in creation; moreover in being the
revealer of the Father; and in being the object of worship.
18. (
continued
). Now in the next place let
us consider the passage in the Proverbs, ‘The Lord created me a
beginning of His ways for His works
2312
;’
although in shewing that the Word is no work, it has been also shewn
that He is no creature. For it is the same
to say work or creature, so that the proof that
He is no work is a proof also that He is no creature. Whereas one may
marvel at these men, thus devising excuses to be irreligious, and
nothing daunted at the refutations which meet them upon every point.
For first they set about deceiving the simple by their questions,
2313
‘Did He who is make from that which
was not one that was not or one that was
2314
?’ and, ‘Had you a son before
begetting him
2315
?’ And when
this had been proved worthless, next they invented the question,
‘Is the Unoriginate one or two
2316
?’ Then,
when in this they had been confuted, straightway they formed another,
‘Has He free-will and an alterable nature
2317
?’ But being forced to give up this,
next they set about saying, ‘Being made so much better than the
Angels
2318
;’ and when the truth exposed
this pretence, now again, collecting them all together, they think to
recommend their heresy by ‘work’ and ‘creature
2319
.’ For they mean those very things over
again, and are true to their own perverseness, putting into various
shapes and turning to and fro the same errors, if so be to deceive some
by that variousness. Although then abundant proof has been given above
of this their reckless expedient, yet, since they make all places sound
with this passage from the Proverbs, and to many who are ignorant of
the faith of Christians, seem to say somewhat, it is necessary to
examine separately, ‘He created’ as well as ‘Who was
faithful to Him that made Him
2320
;’ that, as in
all others, so in this text also, they may be proved to have got no
further than a fantasy.
19. And first let us see the answers, which they
returned to Alexander of blessed memory, in the outset, while their
heresy was in course of formation. They wrote thus: ‘He is a
creature, but not as one of the creatures; a work, but not as one of
the works; an offspring, but not as one of the offsprings
2321
.’ Let every one consider the
profligacy and craft of this heresy; for knowing the bitterness of its
own malignity, it makes an effort to trick itself out with fair words,
and says, what indeed it means, that He is a creature, yet thinks to be
able to screen itself by adding, ‘but not as one of the
creatures.’ However, in thus writing, they rather convict
themselves of irreligion; for if, in your opinion, He is simply a
creature, why add the pretence
2322
, ‘but not as
one of the creatures?’ And if He is simply a work, how ‘not
as one of the works?’ In which we may see the poison of the
heresy. For by saying, ‘offspring, but not as one of the
offsprings,’ they reckon many sons, and one of these they
pronounce to be the Lord; so that according to them He is no more Only
begotten, but one out of many brethren, and is called
2323
offspring and son. What use then is this
pretence of saying that He is a creature and not a creature? for though
ye shall say, Not as ‘one of the creatures,’ I will prove
this sophism of yours to be foolish. For still ye pronounce Him to be
one of the creatures; and whatever a man might say of the other
creatures, such ye hold concerning the Son, ye truly ‘fools and
blind
2324
.’ For is any one of the creatures just
what another is
2325
, that ye should
predicate this of the Son as some prerogative
2326
?
And all the visible creation was made in six days:—in the first,
the light which He called day; in the second the firmament; in the
third, gathering together the waters, He bared the dry land, and
brought out the various fruits that are in it; and in the fourth, He
made the sun and the moon and all the host of the stars; and on the
fifth, He created the race of living things in the sea, and of birds in
the air; and on the sixth, He made the quadrupeds on the earth, and at
length man. And ‘the invisible things of Him from the creation of
the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are
made
2327
;’ and neither the light is as the
night, nor the sun as the moon; nor the irrational as rational man; nor
the Angels as the Thrones, nor the Thrones as the Authorities, yet they
are all creatures, but each of the things made according to its kind
exists and remains in its own
essence, as it was made.
20. Let the Word then be excepted from the works,
and as Creator be restored to the Father, and be confessed to be Son by
nature; or if simply He be a creature, then let Him be assigned the
same condition as the rest one with another, and let them as well as He
be said every one of them to be ‘a creature but not as one of the
creatures, offspring or work, but not as one of the works or
offsprings.’ For ye say that an offspring is the same as a work,
writing ‘generated or made
2328
.’ For
though the Son excel the rest on a comparison, still a creature He is
nevertheless, as they are; since in those which are by nature creatures
one may find some excelling others. Star, for instance, differs from
star in glory, and the rest have all of them their mutual differences
when compared together; yet it follows not for all this that some are
lords, and others servants to the superior, nor that some are efficient
causes
2329
, others by them come into being, but
all have a nature which comes to be and is created, confessing in their
own selves their Framer: as David says in the Psalms, ‘The
heavens declare the glory of God, and the firmament sheweth His handy
work
2330
;’ and as Zorobabel the wise says,
‘All the earth calleth upon the Truth, and the heaven blesseth
it: all works shake and tremble at it
2331
.’ But if the whole earth hymns the
Framer and the Truth, and blesses, and fears it, and its Framer is the
Word, and He Himself says, ‘I am the Truth
2332
,’ it follows that the Word is not a
creature, but alone proper to the Father, in whom all things are
disposed, and He is celebrated by all, as Framer; for ‘I was by
Him disposing
2333
;’ and
‘My Father worketh hitherto, and I work
2334
.’ And the word ‘hitherto’
shews His eternal existence in the Father as the Word; for it is proper
to the Word to work the Father’s works and not to be external to
Him.
21. But if what the Father worketh, that the Son
worketh also
2335
, and what the Son createth, that is
the creation of the Father, and yet the Son be the Father’s work
or creature, then either He will work His own self, and will be His own
creator (since what the Father worketh is the Son’s work also),
which is absurd and impossible; or, in that He creates and worketh the
things of the Father, He Himself is not a work nor a creature; for else
being Himself an efficient cause
2336
, He may cause
that to be in the case of things caused, which He Himself has become,
or rather He may have no power to cause at all.
For how, if, as you hold, He is come of nothing,
is He able to frame things that are nothing into being? or if He, a
creature, withal frames a creature, the same will be conceivable in the
case of every creature, viz. the power to frame others. And if this
pleases you, what is the need of the Word, seeing that things inferior
can be brought to be by things superior? or at all events, every thing
that is brought to be could have heard in the beginning God’s
words, ‘Become’ and ‘be made,’ and so would
have been framed. But this is not so written, nor could it be. For none
of things which are brought to be is an efficient cause, but all things
were made through the Word: who would not have wrought all things, were
He Himself in the number of the creatures. For neither would the Angels
be able to frame, since they too are creatures, though Valentinus, and
Marcion, and Basilides think so, and you are their copyists; nor will
the sun, as being a creature, ever make what is not into what is; nor
will man fashion man, nor stone devise stone, nor wood give growth to
wood. But God is He who fashions man in the womb, and fixes the
mountains, and makes wood grow; whereas man, as being capable of
science, puts together and arranges that material, and works things
that are, as he has learned; and is satisfied if they are but brought
to be, and being conscious of what his nature is, if he needs aught,
knows to ask
2337
it of God.
22. If then God also wrought and compounded out
of materials, this indeed is a gentile thought, according to which God
is an artificer and not a Maker, but yet even in that case let the Word
work the materials, at the bidding and in the service of God
2338
. But if He
calls into existence things which existed not
by His proper Word, then the Word is not in the number of things
non-existing and called; or we have to seek another Word
2339
, through whom He too was called; for by the
Word the things which were not have come to be. And if through Him He
creates and makes, He is not Himself of things created and made; but
rather He is the Word of the Creator God and is known from the
Father’s works which He Himself worketh, to be ‘in the
Father and the Father in Him,’ and ‘He that hath seen Him
hath seen the Father
2340
,’ because the
Son’s Essence is proper to the Father, and He in all points like
Him
2341
. How then does He create through Him, unless
it be His Word and His Wisdom? and how can He be Word and Wisdom,
unless He be the proper offspring of His Essence
2342
, and did not come to be, as others, out of
nothing? And whereas all things are from nothing, and are creatures,
and the Son, as they say, is one of the creatures too and of things
which once were not, how does He alone reveal the Father, and none else
but He know the Father? For could He, a work, possibly know the Father,
then must the Father be also known by all according to the proportion
of the measures of each: for all of them are works as He is. But if it
be impossible for things originate either to see or to know, for the
sight and the knowledge of Him surpasses all (since God Himself says,
‘No one shall see My face and live
2343
’), yet the Son has declared, ‘No
one knoweth the Father, save the Son
2344
,’
therefore the Word is different from all things originate, in that He
alone knows and alone sees the Father, as He says, ‘Not that any
one hath seen the Father, save He that is from the Father,’ and
‘no one knoweth the Father save the Son
2345
,’ though Arius think otherwise. How
then did He alone know, except that He alone was proper to Him? and how
proper, if He were a creature, and not a true Son from Him? (For one
must not mind saying often the same thing for religion’s sake.)
Therefore it is irreligious to think that the Son is one of all things;
and blasphemous and unmeaning to call Him ‘a creature, but not as
one of the creatures, and a work, but not as one of the works, an
offspring, but not as one of the offsprings;’ for how not as one
of these, if, as they say, He was not before His generation
2346
? for it is proper to the creatures and works
not to be before their origination, and to subsist out of nothing, even
though they excel other creatures in glory; for this difference of one
with another will be found in all creatures, which appears in those
which are visible
2347
.
23. Moreover if, as the heretics hold, the Son
were creature or work, but not as one of the creatures, because of His
excelling them in glory, it were natural that Scripture should describe
and display Him by a comparison in His favour with the other works; for
instance, that it should say that He is greater than Archangels, and
more honourable than the Thrones, and both brighter than sun and moon,
and greater than the heavens. But he is not in fact thus referred to;
but the Father shews Him to be His own proper and only Son, saying,
‘Thou art My Son,’ and ‘This is My beloved Son, in
whom I am well pleased.
2348
’ Accordingly
the Angels ministered unto Him, as being one beyond themselves; and
they worship Him, not as being greater in glory, but as being some one
beyond all the creatures, and beyond themselves, and alone the
Father’s proper Son according to essence
2349
.
For if He was worshipped as excelling them in glory, each of things
subservient ought to worship what excels itself. But this is not the
case
2350
; for creature does not worship creature, but
servant Lord, and creature God. Thus Peter the Apostle hinders
Cornelius who would worship him, saying, ‘I myself also am a
man
2351
.’ And an Angel, when John would
worship him in the Apocalypse, hinders him, saying, ‘See thou do
it not; for I am thy fellow-servant, and of thy brethren the Prophets,
and of them that keep the sayings of this book: worship God
2352
.’ Therefore to God alone appertains
worship, and this the very Angels know, that though they excel other
beings in glory, yet they are all creatures and not to be worshipped
2353
, but worship the Lord. Thus Manoah, the
father of
Samson, wishing to offer
sacrifice to the Angel, was thereupon hindered by him, saying,
‘Offer not to me, but to God
2354
.’ On the
other hand, the Lord is worshipped even by the Angels; for it is
written, ‘Let all the Angels of God worship Him
2355
;’ and by all the Gentiles, as Isaiah
says, ‘The labour of Egypt and merchandize of Ethiopia and of the
Sabeans, men of stature, shall come over unto thee, and they shall be
thy servants;’ and then, ‘they shall fall down unto thee,
and shall make supplication unto thee, saying, Surely God is in thee,
and there is none else, there is no God
2356
.’ And He accepts His disciples’
worship, and certifies them who He is, saying, ‘Call ye Me not
Lord and Master? and ye say well, for so I am.’ And when Thomas
said to Him, ‘My Lord and my God
2357
,’ He allows his words, or rather
accepts him instead of hindering him. For He is, as the other Prophets
declare, and David says in the Psalm, ‘the Lord of hosts, the
Lord of Sabaoth,’ which is interpreted, ‘the Lord of
Armies,’ and God True and Almighty, though the Arians burst
2358
at the tidings.
24. But He had not been thus worshipped, nor been
thus spoken of, were He a creature merely. But now since He is not a
creature, but the proper offspring of the Essence of that God who is
worshipped, and His Son by nature, therefore He is worshipped and is
believed to be God, and is Lord of armies, and in authority, and
Almighty, as the Father is; for He has said Himself, ‘All things
that the Father hath, are Mine
2359
.’ For it is
proper to the Son, to have the things of the Father, and to be such
that the Father is seen in Him, and that through Him all things were
made, and that the salvation of all comes to pass and consists in
Him.
2312
Prov. viii.
22
.
[This text, which had been immemorially applied to the
Λόγος
(
supr.
p. 168, note 7), and which in the false
rendering of the LXX. strongly favoured the Arian side], is presently
explained at greater length than any other of the texts he handles,
forming the chief subject of the Oration henceforth, after an
introduction which extends down to 44.
2313
From
the methodical manner in which the successive portions of his foregoing
Oration are here referred to, it would almost seem as if he were
answering in course some Arian work. vid. also
supr. Orat.
i.
37, 53.
infr. Orat.
iii. 26. He does not seem to be tracing the
controversy historically.
2314
Supr.
ch. vii.
2315
Ch.
viii.
2316
Ch.
ix.
2317
Ch.
x.
2318
Ch.
xiii.
2319
Ch.
xiv. and xv.
2320
Ch.
xiv.
Heb. iii. 2
2321
Vid.
Arius’s letter,
de Syn.
16. This was the sophism by means
of which Valens succeeded with the Fathers of Arminium. vid. S. Jerome
in Luciferian.
18. vid. also in Eusebius,
supr. Ep. Eus.
6.
2322
De
Syn.
32.
2323
υἵον
χρηματίζειν
. The question between Catholics and Arians was whether our
Lord was a true Son, or only
called
Son. ‘Since they
whisper something about Word and Wisdom as only
names
of the
Son, &c.’
ὀνόματα
μόνον
,
supr.
i. 26, note 1, and
de Decr.
16, note 10. And so ‘the title
of Image is not a token of a similar substance, but His
name
only,’
supr.
i. 21, and so
infr.
38. where
τοῖς
ὀνόμασι
is
synonymous with
κατ᾽
ἐπίνοιαν
, as
Sent. D.
22. f. a. Vid. also 39.
Orat.
iii. 11.
18. ‘not named Son, but ever Son,’ iv. 24. fin.
Ep.
Æg.
16. ‘We call Him so, and mean truly what we say;
they say it, but do not confess it.’ Chrysost. in
Act.
Hom.
33. 4. vid. also
νόθοις
ὥσπερ
ὀνόμασι
,
Cyril.
de Trin.
ii. p. 418. Non hæc nuda nomina, Ambros.
de Fid.
i. 17. Yet, since the Sabellians equally failed here,
also considering the Sonship as only a notion or title, vid.
Orat.
iv. 2. (where in contrast, ‘The Father is Father,
and the Son Son,’ vid. supr. p. 319, note 1.) 12. 23. 25. the
word ‘real’ was used as against
them,
and in
opposition to
ἀνυπόστατος
λόγος
by the Arians,
and in consequence failed as a test of orthodox teaching; e.g. by
Arius,
supr.
p. 97. by Euseb.
in Marc.
pp. 19, d. 35, b.
161, c. by Asterius,
infr.
37. by Palladius and Secundus in the
Council of Aquileia ap. Ambros.
Opp.
t. 2. p. 791. (ed. Bened.)
by Maximinus ap. August.
contr. Max.
i. 6.
2324
Matt. xxiii.
19
.
2325
And
so S. Ambrose, Quæ enim creatura non sicut alia creatura non est?
Homo non ut Angelus, terra non ut cœlum.
de Fid.
i. n. 130,
and a similar passage in Nyss.
contr. Eun.
iii. p. 132,
3.
2326
ἐξαίρετον
. vid.
infr. Orat.
iii. 3. init. iv. 28. init. Euseb.
Eccl. Theol.
pp. 47. b. 73. b. 89. b. 124. a. 129. c. Theodor.
H. E.
p. 732. Nyss.
contr. Eunom.
iii. p. 133. a. Epiph.
Hær
. 76. p. 970. Cyril.
Thes.
p. 160.
2327
Rom. i. 20
.
2328
γεννηθέντα
ἢ
ποιηθέντα
; as if they were synonymous; in opposition to which the
Nicene Creed says,
γεννηθέντα
ἢ
ποιηθέντα
. In like manner Arius in his letter to Eusebius uses the
words,
πρὶν
γεννηθῇ ἤτοι
κτισθῇ, ἢ
ὀρισθῇ, ἢ
θεμελιωθῇ
, Theodor.
H. E.
p. 750. And to Alexander,
ἀχρόνως
γεννηθεὶς
καὶ πρὸ αἰ&
240·νων
κτισθεὶς καὶ
θεμελιωθείς·
de Syn.
16. And
Eusebius to Paulinus,
κτιστὸν καὶ
θεμελιωτὸν
καὶ
γεννητόν
Theod. p. 752. The different words profess to be Scriptural, and
to explain each other; ‘created’ being in
Prov. viii.
22
.
‘made’ in the passages considered in the last two chapters,
‘appointed’ or ‘declared’ in
Rom. i.
4
.
and ‘founded’ or ‘established’ in
Prov. viii.
23
.
which is discussed
infr.
22, &c. vid. also 52.
2329
21,
note 2.
2330
Ps. xix. 1
.
2331
1 Esdr. iv.
36
.
2332
John xiv. 6
.
2333
Prov. viii.
30
,
LXX.
2334
John v. 17
.
2335
Orat.
iii. 11. note.
2336
ποιητικὸν
αἴτιον
, also,
infr.
27. and
Orat.
iii. 14. and
contr. Gent.
9
init. No creature can create, vid. e.g. about Angels, August.
de
Civ. Dei
xii. 24.
de Trin.
iii. 13–18. Damasc.
F.
O.
ii. 3. Cyril
in Julian,
ii. p. 62. ‘Our reason
rejects the idea that the Creator should be a creature, for creation is
by the Creator.’ Hil.
Trin.
xii. 5.
πῶς
δύναται τὸ
κτιζόμενον
κτίζειν; ἢ
πῶς ὁ κτίζων
κτίζεται
; Athan.
ad Afros.
4 fin. Vid. also
Serap.
i. 24, 6.
iii. 4, e. The Gnostics who attributed creation to Angels are alluded
to
infr. Orat.
iii. 12. Epiph.
Hær.
52. 53, 163,
&c. Theodor.
Hær.
i. 1 and 3.
2337
De
Decr.
11.
2338
προσταττόμενος
καὶ
ὑπουργῶν
. It is not quite clear that Athan. accepts these words in his own
person, as has been assumed
de Decr.
9. note 2,
de Syn.
27 (3). Vid.
de Decr.
7. and
infr.
24. and 31, which, as
far as they go, are against the use of the word. Also S. Basil objects
to
ὑποῦργος
contr. Eunom.
ii. 21. and S.
Cyril in
Joan.
p. 48. though S. Basil speaks of
τὸν
προστάττοντα
κύριον
. i. 46,
note 3. and S. Cyril of the Son’s
ὑποταγή
,
Thesaur.
p. 255. Vid. ‘ministering,
ὑπηρετοῦντα
, to the Father of all.’ Just.
Tryph.
p. 72.
‘The Word become minister,
ὑπηρέτης
, of the Creator,’ Origen
Hom. in Joan.
p. 61. also
Constit. Ap.
viii. 12. but Pseudo-Athan. objects to
ὑπηρετῶν
,
de Comm. Essent.
30. and Athan. apparently,
infr.
28. Again, ‘Whom did He order, præcepit?’ Iren.
Hær.
iii. 8. n. 3. ‘The Father bids,
ἐντέλλεται
(allusion to
Ps. xxxiii. 9
. vid.
infr.
31), the
Word accomplishes.…He who commands,
κελεύων
, is the Father, He who obeys,
ὑπακούων
, the Son.…The Father willed,
ἠθέλησεν
, the Son did it.’ Hippol.
contr. Noet.
14. on which
Fabricius’s note. S. Hilary speaks of the Son as ‘subditus
per obedientiæ obsequelam.’
de Syn.
51. Vid. below,
on §31. In note 8 there the principle is laid down for the use of
these expressions. [
Supr.
p. 87, note 2.]
2339
Cf.
Ep. Æg.
14. vid. also
supr.
p. 155. and
Orat.
iii. 2. 64. Aug. in
Joan. Tract.
i. 11. Vid. a parallel argument
with reference to the Holy Spirit.
Serap.
i. 25. b.
2340
Vid.
John xiv. 9, 10
.
2341
τὴν κατὰ
πάντα
ὁμοιότητα
: vid. parallel instances,
de Syn.
26 (5) note 1,
which add,
ὅμοιος
κατὰ πάντα
,
Orat.
i. 40.
κατὰ πάντα
καὶ ἐν πᾶσι
,
Ep. Æg.
17, c.
τοῦ πατρὸς
ὅμοιος
,
Orat.
ii. 17.
Orat.
iii. 20, a. ‘not
ὅμοιος
, as the
Church preaches, but
ὡς αὐτοὶ
θέλουσι᾽
(vid. p. 289, note 4), also
de Syn.
53, note 9.
2342
As
Sonship is implied in ‘Image’ (
supr.
§2, note
2), so it is implied in ‘Word’ and ‘Wisdom.’
Orat.
iv. 15.
Orat.
iii. 29 init.
de Decr.
17. And
still more pointedly,
Orat.
iv. 24 fin. vid. also
supr.
i. 28, note 5. And so ‘Image is implied in Sonship: ‘being
Son of God He must be like Him,’
supr.
17. And so
‘Image’ is implied in Word;’
ἐν
τῇ ἰδί& 139·
εἰκόνι, ἥτις
ἐστὶν ὁ
λόγος
αὐτοῦ
,
infr.
82, d. also 34, c. On the contrary, the very root of heretical error
was the denial that these titles implied each other, vid.
supr.
27,
de Decr.
17, 24, notes.
2343
Vid.
Ex. xxxiii. 20
.
2344
Matt. xi. 27
.
2345
John vi. 46
, not to the
letter.
2346
Vid.
supr.
1. and
Exc. B
.
2347
Greek
text dislocated.
2348
Ps. ii. 7
;
Matt. iii.
17
.
2349
De
Decr.
10.
2350
Vid.
Orat.
iii. 12.
2351
Acts x. 26
.
2352
Rev. xxii. 9
.
2353
[A
note, to the effect that ‘worship’ is an ambiguous term, is
omitted here.]
2354
Vid.
Judg. xiii. 16
.
2355
Heb. i. 6
.
2356
Is. xlv. 14
.
2357
John xiii. 13
; xx.
28.
2358
διαῤ&
191·ηγνύωσιν
ἑαυτούς·
also
ad Adelph.
8. and vid.
supr.
note on
de
Decr.
17. vid. also
διαῤ&
191·ηγνύωνται
,
de Syn.
54,
καὶ διαῤ&
191·αγοῖεν
,
Marcell. ap. Euseb.
Eccl. Theol.
p. 116. also p. 40
τρίζωσι
τοὺς
ὀδόντως
,
de Fug.
26. init.
τριζέτωσαν
,
ad Adelph.
8.
Hist. Ar.
68. fin. and
literally 72. a.
κόπτουσιν
ἑαυτούς
.
In illud Omnia
5.
2359
John xvi. 15
.