ring baptism is what he possesses who is ordained. And as the baptized person, if he depart
from the unity of the Church, does not thereby lose the sacrament of baptism, so also he
who is ordained, if he depart from the unity of the Church, does not lose the sacrament of
conferring baptism. For neither sacrament may be wronged. If a sacrament necessarily
becomes void in the case of the wicked, both must become void; if it remain valid with the
wicked, this must be so with both. If, therefore, the baptism be acknowledged which he
could not lose who severed himself from the unity of the Church, that baptism must also
be acknowledged which was administered by one who by his secession had not lost the
sacrament of conferring baptism. For as those who return to the Church, if they had been
baptized before their secession, are not rebaptized, so those who return, having been ordained
before their secession, are certainly not ordained again; but either they again exercise their
former ministry, if the interests of the Church require it, or if they do not exercise it, at any
rate they retain the sacrament of their ordination; and hence it is, that when hands are laid
on them,1149 to mark their reconciliation, they are not ranked with the laity. For Feli-
cianus,1150 when he separated himself from them with Maximianus, was not held by the
Donatists themselves to have lost either the sacrament of baptism or the sacrament of con-
ferring baptism. For now he is a recognized member of their own body, in company with
those very men whom he baptized while he was separated from them in the schism of
Maximianus. And so others could receive from them, whilst they still had not joined our
society, what they themselves had not lost by severance from our society. And hence it is
clear that they are guilty of impiety who endeavor to rebaptize those who are in Catholic
unity; and we act rightly who do not dare to repudiate God’s sacraments, even when admin-
istered in schism. For in all points in which they think with us, they also are in communion
with us, and only are severed from us in those points in which they dissent from us. For
contact and disunion are not to be measured by different laws in the case of material or
spiritual affinities. For as union of bodies arises from continuity of position, so in the
agreement of wills there is a kind of contact between souls. If, therefore, a man who has
severed himself from unity wishes to do anything different from that which had been im-
pressed on him while in the state of unity, in this point he does sever himself, and is no
longer a part of the united whole; but wherever he desires to conduct himself as is customary
1149 Comp. v. 23, and iii. 16, note.
1150 Felicianus, bishop of Musti, headed the revolt against Primianus, the successor of Parmenianus in the
Carthaginian See. Listening to the complaint of the deacon Maximianus, who had been deposed by Primianus,
a synod was convened in 393 at Cabarsussis, which ordained Maximianus as bishop of Carthage. Hence the
title Maximianistæ. Primianus, in 394, at the council of Bagai, was recognized by 310 bishops. The larger fraction,
according to the Catholics, was subsequently forced into reunion. Prætextatus, bp. of Assuris, was also one of
the leaders in this separation.
698
Chapter 1