Elucidations.
————————————
I.
(Deadly Sins, cap. ix., p. 356.
)
To
maintain a modern and
wholly uncatholic system of Penitence, the schoolmen invented a
technical scheme of sins
mortal
and sins
venial
, which
must not be read into the Fathers, who had no such technicalities in
mind. By “deadly sins” they meant all such as St. John
recognizes (
1 John v.
16–17
) and none
other; that is to say sins of surprise and infirmity, sins having in
them no malice or wilful disobedience, such as an impatient word, or a
momentary neglect of duty. Should a dying man commit a deliberate sin
and then expire, even after a life of love and obedience, who could
fail to recognize the fearful nature of such an end? But, should
his last word be one of infirmity and weakness, censurable but not
involving wilful disobedience, surely we may consider it as provided
for by the comfortable words—“there is a sin not unto
death.” Yet “all unrighteousness is sin,” and the
Fathers held that all sin should be repented of and confessed before
God; because all sin when it
is finished
bringeth forth
death.”
In St. Augustine’s time, when moral theology
became systematized in the West, by his mighty genius and influence,
the following were recognized degrees of guilt: (1.) Sins deserving
excommunication. (2.) Sins requiring to be confessed to the brother
offended in order to God’s forgiveness, and (3.) sins covered by
God’s gracious covenant, when daily confessed in the Lord’s
Prayer, in public, or in private. And this classification was
professedly based on Holy Scripture. Thus: (1.) on the
text—“To deliver such an one unto Satan, etc.”
(
1 Cor. v.
4–5
). (2.) On the
text—(
Matt. xviii.
15
), “Confess your sins
one to another, brethren” (
James v. 16
), and (3.) on the
text—(
Matt. vi.
12
) “Forgive us
our trespasses as we forgive them that trespass against
us.” This last St. Augustine
5190
regards as the “daily medication” of our ordinary life,
habitual penitence and faith and the baptismal covenant being
presupposed.
The modern Trent theology has vastly amplified the
scholastic teachings and refinements, and the elevation of Liguori to
the rank of a church-doctor has virtually made the whole system
de
fide
with the Latins. The Easterns know nothing of this
modern and uncatholic teaching, and it is important that the student of
the Ante-Nicene
Patrologia
should be on his guard against the
novel meanings which the Trent theology imposes upon orthodox (Nicene)
language. The long ages during which Eastern orthodoxy has been
obscured by
the sufferings and
consequent ignorance of the Greeks, have indeed tainted their doctrinal
and practical system, but it still subsists in amazing contrast with
Latin impurity. See, on the “indulgences,” of the latter,
the “Orthodox Theology of Macarius, Bishop of Vinnitza,”
Tom. II. p. 541, Paris, 1860.
II.
(Reservation of Baptism, cap. xi., note, p. 361.)
It is important, here, to observe the heretical origin
of a sinful superstition which becomes conspicuous in the history of
Constantine. If the church tolerated it in his case, it was doubtless
in view of this extraordinary instance of one, who was a heathen still,
at heart, becoming a guardian and protector of the persecuted Faithful.
It is probable that he was regarded as a Cyrus or a Nebuchadnezzar whom
God had raised up to protect and to deliver His people; who was to be
honoured and obeyed as “God’s minister” (
Rom. xiii. 4
.) in so far, and for this purpose. The
church was scrupulous and he was superstitious; it would have been
difficult to discipline him and worse not to discipline him. Tacitly,
therefore, he was treated as a
catechumen
, but was not
formally admitted even to that class. He permitted Heathenism, and
while he did so, how could he be received as a Christian? The Christian
church never became responsible for his life and character, but strove
to reform him and to prepare him for a true confession of Christ at
some “convenient season.” In this, there seems to have been
a great fault somewhere, chargeable perhaps to Eusebius or to some
other Christian counsellor; but, when could any one
say—“the emperor is sincere and humble and penitent and
ought now to be received into the church.” It was a
political
conversion, and as such was accepted, and Constantine
was a heathen till near his death. As to his final penitence and
acceptance—“Forbear to judge.”
2 Kings x. 29–31
. Concerning his baptism, see
Eusebius,
de Vita Const.
iv. 61, see also, Mosheim’s
elaborate and candid views of the whole subject:
First Three
Centuries
, Vol. II. 460–471.
III.
(Peter, cap. xiii. p. 365.)
The great Gallican, Launoy, doctor of the
Sorbonne, has proved that the Fathers understand the Rock to be Christ,
while, only rarely, and that
rhetorically
, not dogmatically, St.
Peter is called a stone or a rock; a usage to which neither Luther nor
Calvin could object. Tertullian himself, when he speaks
dogmatically, is in accord with other Fathers, and gives no countenance
to the modern doctrine of Rome. See
La
Papauté
, of the
Abbé
Guettée
, pp. 42–61. It is important, also, to
note that the primacy of St. Peter, more or less, whatever it may have
been in the mind of the Fathers, was wholly
personal
, in their
view. Of the fables which make it hereditary and a purtenance of Rome
they knew nothing.
IV.
(Loans, cap. xvii. p. 372.)
The whole subject of
usury
, in what it
consists,
etc.
, deserves to receive more attention than it does
in our times, when
nominal
Christians are
steeped
in the
sin of money-traffic to the injury of neighbours, on a scale truly
gigantic. God’s word clearly rebukes this sin. So does the
Council of Nice.
5191
Now by what is the
sin defined? Certainly by the
spirit
of the Gospel; but, is it
also, by the letter? A sophistical casuistry which maintains the
letter, and then sophisticates and refines so as to explain it all
away, is the product of school divinity and of modern Jesuitry; but
even the great Bossuet is its apologist. (See his
Traité de l’Usure
. opp. ix. p. 49, etc., ed.
Paris, 1846.) But for an exhaustive review of the whole matter, I ask
attention to Huet,
Le Règne Social
,
etc. (Paris, 1853) pp. 334–345.
V.
(The Baptist, cap. xviii. p. 375.)
The interpretation of Tertullian, however, has the
all-important merit (which Bacon and Hooker recognize as cardinal) of
flowing from the Scripture without squeezing. (1.) Our Lord sent the
message to John as a personal and tender assurance to
him
. (2.)
The story illustrates the
decrease
of which the Baptist had
spoken prophetically (
John iii. 30
.); and (3.) it sustains the great
principle that Christ alone is without sin, this being the one fault
recorded of the Baptist, otherwise a singular instance of sinlessness.
The B. Virgin’s fault (gently reproved by the Lord,
John ii. 4
.), seems in like manner introduced on
this principle of exhibiting the only sinless One, in His Divine
perfections as without spot. So even Joseph and Moses (
Psalm cvi. 33
., and
Gen. xlvii. 20
.) are shewn “to be but men.”
The policy of Joseph has indeed been extravagantly censured.
VI.
(Harshness, cap. xix., note 6., p. 378. Also, cap. xxvi.
p. 393.)
Tertullian seems with reflect the early view of the
church as to our Lord’s total abnegation of all filial relations
with the Virgin, when He gave to her St. John, instead of Himself, on
the Cross. For this purpose He had made him the beloved disciple and
doubtless charged him with all the duties with which he was to be
clothed. Thus He fulfilled the figurative law of His priesthood,
as given by Moses, (
Deut.
xxxiii. 9
.) and crucified
himself, from the beginning, according to his own Law (
Luke xiv. 26–27
.) which he identifies with the Cross,
here and also in
Matt. x.
37–38
. These then
are the steps of His own holy example, illustrating His own precept,
for doubtless, as “the Son of man,” His filial love was
superlative and made the sacrifice the sharper: (1.) He taught Joseph
that He had no earthly father, when he said—“Wist ye not
that I must be in
my Father’s house
,”
(
Luke iii.
49
., Revised); but, having
established this fact, he then became “subject” to both his
parents, till His public ministry began. (2.) At this time, He seems to
have admonished His mother, that He could not recognize her authority
any longer, (
John ii.
4
.) having now entered upon
His work as the Son of God. (3.) Accordingly, He refused, thenceforth,
to know her save only as one of His redeemed, excepting her in nothing
from this common work for all the Human Race, (
Matt. xii. 48
) in the passage which Tertullian so
forcibly expounds. (4.) Finally, when St. Mary draws near to the cross,
apparently to claim the final recognition of the previous understanding
(
John ii. 4
.) to which the Lord had referred her at
Cana—He fulfils His last duty to her in giving her a son instead
of Himself, and thereafter (5) recognizes her no more; not even in His
messages after the Resurrection, nor when He met her with other
disciples. He rewards her, instead, with the infinite love He bears to
all His saints, and with the brightest rewards which are bestowed upon
Faith. In this consists her superlative excellence and her conspicuous
glory among the Redeemed (
Luke
i. 47–48
.) in
Christ’s account.
VII.
(Children, cap. xxiii. p. 386.)
In this beautiful testimony of our author to the
sanctity of marriage, and the blessedness of its fruits, I see his
austere spirit reflecting the spirit of Christ so tenderly and so
faithfully, in the love of children, that I am warmly drawn to him. I
cannot give him up to Montanism at this period of his life and labours.
Surely, he was as yet merely persuaded that the prophetic
charismata
were not extinct, and that
they had been received by his
Phrygian friends, although he may still
have regarded them as
prophesying
subject to all the infirmities
which St. Paul attributes even to persons elevated by spiritual gifts.
(
1 Cor. xiv
.) Why not recognize him in all his
merits, until his open and senile lapse is complete?
VIII.
(Hades, cap. xxxiv. p. 406.)
Here again our author shews his unsettled view as
to
Sheol
or
Hades
, on which see Kaye, pp. 247–250.
Here he distinguishes between the
Inferi
and Abraham’s
bosom; but (in B. iii. cap. 24.) he has already, more aptly, regarded
the
Inferi
, or
Hades
, as the common receptacle of
departed spirits, where a “great gulf” indeed, separates
between the two classes.
A
caricature
may sometimes illustrate
characteristic features more powerfully than a true portrait. The
French call the highest gallery in theatres,
paradis
; and I have sometimes explained it by the
fact that the modern drama originated in the monkish
Mysteries
,
revived so profanely in our own day. To reconcile the poor to a bad
place they gave it the name of
Paradise
, thus illustrating their
Mediæval conceptions; for trickling down from Tertullian his vivid
notions seem to have suffused all Western theology on this subject.
Thus, then, one vast receptacle receives all the dead. The
pit
,
as we very appropriately call it in English, answers to the place of
lost spirits, where the rich man was in torments. Above, are
ranged the family of Abraham reclining, as it were, in their
father’s bosom, by turns. Far above, under skylights, (for the
old Mysteries were celebrated in the day-time) is
the Paradise
,
where the Martyrs see God, and are represented as “under the
altar” of heaven itself. Now, abandoning our grotesque
illustration, but using it for its
topography
, let us conceive
of our own globe, as having a world-wide concavity such as they
imagined, from literalizing the
under-world
of Sheol. In its
depths is the
Phylace
(
1 Peter iii. 19
.) of “spirits in
prison.” In a higher region repose the blessed spirits in
“Abraham’s bosom.” Yet nearer to the ethereal
vaults, are the martyrs in Paradise, looking out into heavenly worlds.
The immensity of the scale does not interfere with the vision of
spirits, nor with such communications as Abraham holds with his lost
son in the history of Dives and Lazarus. Here indeed Science comes to
our aid, for if the
telephone
permits such conversations while
we are in the flesh, we may at least imagine that the subtile spirit
can act in like manner, apart from such contrivances. Now, so far as
Tertullian is consistent with himself, I think these explanations may
clarify his words and references. The Eastern Theology is less
inconsistent and bears the marks alike of Plato and of Origen.
But of this hereafter. Of
a place
, such as the Mediæval
Purgatory
, affirmed as
de fide
by the Trent creed, the
Fathers knew nothing at all. See Vol. II. p. 490, also 522, this
Series.
5190
Opp. Tom. vi. p. 228.
Ed. Migne.
5191
Calmet. Opp. i. 483
and Tom. x., p. 525.