SECT. VIII.
The notion of moral sincerity’s being the qualification, which gives a lawful right to
christian sacraments, examined.
Though our author disdains the imputation of any such notion, as that of men’s being
called visible and professed saints from respect to a visibility and profession of moral sincerity:
yet it is manifest, that in his scheme (whether consistently or no, others must judge) moral
sincerity is the qualification which entitles, and gives a lawful right, to sacraments. For he
holds, that it is lawful for unsanctified men, who have this qualification, to come to sacra-
ments; and that it is not lawful for them to come without it. Therefore I desire this notion
may be thoroughly examined.
And for the greater clearness, let it be observed what sincerity in general is. Now sincerity,
in the general notion of it, is an honest conformity of some profession or outward show of
some inward property or act of mind, to the truth and reality of it. If there be a show or pre-
tence of what is not, and has no real existence, then the pretence is altogether vain; it is only
a pretence, and nothing else: and therefore is a pretence or show without any sincerity, of
any kind, either moral or gracious.
503
I now proceed to offer the following arguments against the notion of moral sincerity
being the qualification, which gives a lawful right to sacraments.
I. There is no such thing as moral sincerity, in the covenant of grace, distinct from gra-
cious sincerity. If any sincerity at all be requisite in order to a title to the seals of the covenant
of grace, doubtless it is the sincerity which belongs to that covenant. But there is only one
sort of sincerity which belongs to that covenant; and that is a gracious sincerity. There is
but one sort of faith belonging to that covenant; and that is saving faith in Jesus Christ,
called in Scripture unfeigned faith. As for the faith of devils, it is not the faith of the covenant
of grace.
Here the distinction of an internal and external covenant, will not help at all; as long as
the covenant, of which the sacraments are seals, is a covenant of salvation, or a covenant
proposing terms of eternal salvation. The sacraments are seals of such a covenant. They are
seals of the New Testament in Christ’s blood, (Matt. xxvi. 28. Luke xxii. 28.) a Testament
which has better promises than the Old, (Heb. viii. 6.) and which the apostle tells us, makes
us heirs of the eternal inheritance. (Heb. ix. 15.)—Mr. W. himself speaks of the covenant
sealed in baptism, as the covenant proposing terms of salvation. (p. 23. b. c.) So he speaks of
the covenant entered into by a visible people, as the covenant in which God offers everlasting
happiness. (p 24, 25.) But there is no other religion, no other sincerity, belonging to this
covenant of salvation, but that which accompanies salvation, or is saving religion and sincerity.
As it is written, () “Behold, thou desirest truth in the inward parts.”
There is what may be called a moral sincerity, in distinction from saving, in many
moral things; as in loving our friends and neighbours, in loving our country, in choosing
SECTION VIII. Of sincerity.
1947
SECTION VIII. Of sincerity.