On Bk. V. Introd. § I (note 3, continued). The Successors of Antoninus Pius.
Antoninus Pius was succeeded in 161 by his adopted sons, Marcus Aurelius Antoninus
Verus and Lucius Ceionius Ælius Aurelius Commodus Antoninus. Upon his accession to
the throne the former transferred his name Verus to the latter, who was thenceforth called
Lucius Aurelius Verus. In his Chronicle Eusebius keeps these two princes distinct, but in
his History he falls into sad confusion in regard to them, and this confusion has drawn upon
him the severe censure of all his critics. He knew of course, as every one did, that Antoninus
Pius had two successors. In Bk. IV. chap. 14, § 10, he states this directly, and gives the names
of the successors as “Marcus Aurelius Verus, who was also called Antoninus,” and “Lucius.”
From that point on he calls the former of these princes simply Antoninus Verus, Antoninus,
or Verus, dropping entirely the name Marcus Aurelius. In Bk. IV. chap. 18, § 2, he speaks
of the emperor “whose times we are now recording,” that is, the successor of Antoninus
Pius, and calls him Antoninus Verus. In Bk. V. Introd. § I he refers to the same emperor as
Antoninus Verus, and in Bk. V. chap. 4, § 3, and chap. 9, he calls him simply Antoninus,
while in Bk. IV. chap. 13, § 8, he speaks of him as the “Emperor Verus.” The death of this
Emperor Antoninus is mentioned in Bk. V. chap. 9, and it is there said that he reigned
nineteen years and was then succeeded by Commodus. It is evident that in all these passages
he is referring to the emperor whom we know as Marcus Aurelius, but to whom he gives
that name only once, when he records his accession to the empire. On the other hand, in
Bk. V. chap. 5, § 1, Eusebius speaks of Marcus Aurelius Cæsar and expressly distinguishes
him from the Emperor Antoninus, to whom he has referred at the close of the previous
chapter, and makes him the brother of that emperor. Again, in the same chapter, § 6, he
calls this Marcus Aurelius Cæsar, just referred to, the “Emperor Marcus,” still evidently
distinguishing him from the Emperor Antoninus. In this chapter, therefore, he thinks of
Marcus Aurelius as the younger of the two sons left by Antoninus Pius; that is, he identifies
him with the one whom we call Lucius Verus, and whom he himself calls Lucius in Bk. IV.
chap. 14 § 10. Eusebius thus commits a palpable error. How are we to explain it?
The explanation seems to me to lie in the circumstance that Eusebius attempted to re-
concile the tradition that Marcus Aurelius was not a persecutor with the fact known to him
as a historian, that the emperor who succeeded Antoninus Pius was. It was the common
belief in the time of Eusebius, as it had been during the entire preceding century, that all
391
the good emperors had been friendly to the Christians, and that only the bad emperors had
persecuted. Of course, among the good emperors was included the philosophical Marcus
Aurelius (cf. e.g. Tertullian’s Apol. chap. 5, to which Eusebius refers in Bk. V. chap. 5). It
was of Marcus Aurelius, moreover, that the story of the Thundering Legion was told (see
ibid.). But Eusebius was not able to overlook the fact that numerous martyrdoms occurred
during the reign of the successor of Antoninus Pius. He had the documents recording the
terrible persecution at Lyons and Vienne; he had an apology of Melito, describing the
On Bk. V. Introd. § I (note 3, continued). The Successors of Antoninus Pius.
1001
On Bk. V. Introd. § I (note 3, continued). The Successors of Antoninus …