200
Book VIII.
§1. The eighth book very notably overthrows the blasphemy of the heretics who say that
the Only-begotten came from nothing, and that there was a time when He was not, and shows
the Son to be no new being, but from everlasting, from His having said to Moses, “I am He
that is,” and to Manoah, “Why askest thou My name? It also is wonderful”;—moreover David
also says to God, “Thou art the same, and Thy years shall not fail;” and furthermore Isaiah
says, “I am God, the first, and hereafter am I:” and the Evangelist, “He was in the beginning,
and was with God, and was God:”—and that He has neither beginning nor end: —and he
proves that those who say that He is new and comes from nothing are idolaters. And herein
he very finely interprets “the brightness of the glory, and the express image of the Person.”
These, then, are the strong points of Eunomius’ case; and I think that when those which
promised to be powerful are proved by argument to be so rotten and unsubstantial, I may
well keep silence concerning the rest, since the others are practically refuted, concurrently
with the refutation of the stronger ones; just as it happens in warlike operations that when
a force more powerful than the rest has been beaten, the remainder of the army are no longer
of any account in the eyes of those by whom the strong portion of it has been overcome.
But the fact that the chief part of his blasphemy lies in the later part of his discourse forbids
me to be silent. For the transition of the Only-begotten from nothing into being, that horrid
and godless doctrine of Eunomius, which is more to be shunned than all impiety, is next
maintained in the order of his argument. And since every one who has been bewitched by
this deceit has the phrase, “If He was, He has not been begotten, and if He has been begotten,
He was not,” ready upon his tongue for the maintenance of the doctrine that He Who made
of nothing us and all the creation is Himself from nothing, and since the deceit obtains
much support thereby, as men of feebler mind are pressed by this superficial bit of plausib-
ility, and led to acquiesce in the blasphemy, we must needs not pass by this doctrinal “root
of bitterness,” lest, as the Apostle says, it “spring up and trouble us849.” Now I say that we
must first of all consider the actual argument itself, apart from our contest with our oppon-
ents, and thus afterwards proceed to the examination and refutation of what they have set
forth.
One mark of the true Godhead is indicated by the words of Holy Scripture, which Moses
learnt by the voice from heaven, when He heard Him Who said, “I am He that is850.” We
think it right, then, to believe that to be alone truly Divine which is represented as eternal
and infinite in respect of being; and all that is contemplated therein is always the same,
neither growing nor being consumed; so that if one should say of God, that formerly He
was, but now is not, or that He now is, but formerly was not, we should consider each of
849 Cf. Heb. xii. 15
850 Exod. iii. 4.
Book VIIIThe eighth book very notably overthrows the blasphemy of the heretics who say that the Only-begotten came from nothing, and that there was a time when He was not, and shows the Son to be no new being, but from everlasting, from His having said to Moses, “I am He that is,” and to Manoah, “Why askest thou My name? It also is wonderful”;--moreover David also says to God, “Thou art the same, and Thy years shall not fail;” and furthermore Isaiah says, “I am God, the first, and hereafter am I:” and the Evangelist, “He was in the beginning, and was with God, and was God:”--and that He has neither beginning nor end: --and he proves that those who say that He is new and comes from nothing are idolaters. And herein he very finely interprets “the brightness of the glory, and the express image of the Person.”
384
Book VIII