Book X.
Faustus insists that the Old Testament promises are radically different from those of
the New. Augustin admits a difference, but maintains that the moral precepts are the same
in both.
1. Faustus said: Another reason for not receiving the Old Testament is, that both the
Old and the New teach us not to covet what belongs to others. Everything in the Old Test-
177
ament is of this kind. It promises riches, and plenty, and children, and children’s children,
and long life, and withal the land of Canaan; but only to the circumcised, the Sabbath ob-
servers, those offering sacrifices, and abstaining from swine’s flesh. Now I, like every other
Christian, pay no attention to these things, as being trifling and useless for the salvation of
the soul. I conclude, therefore, that the promises do not belong to me. And mindful of the
commandment, Thou shall not covet, I gladly leave to the Jews their own property, and
content myself with the gospel, and with the bright inheritance of the kingdom of heaven.
If a Jew were to claim part in the gospel, I should justly reproach him with claiming what
he had no right to, because he does not obey its precepts. And a Jew might say the same to
me if I professed to receive the Old Testament while I disregard its requirements.
2. Augustin replied: Faustus is not ashamed to repeat the same nonsense again and
again. But it is tiresome to repeat the same answers, though it is to repeat truth. What
Faustus says here has already been answered.376 But if a Jew asks me why I profess to believe
the Old Testament while I do not observe its precepts, my reply is this: The moral precepts
of the law are observed by Christians; the symbolical precepts were properly observed during
the time that the things now revealed were prefigured. Accordingly, those observances,
which I regard as no longer binding, I still look upon as a testimony, as I do also the carnal
promises from which the Old Testament derives its name. For although the gospel teaches
me to hope for eternal blessings, I also find a confirmation of the gospel in those things
which "happened to them for an example, and were written for our admonition, on whom
the ends of the world are come." So much for our answer to the Jews. And now we have
something to say to the Manichæans.
3. By showing the way in which we regard the authority of the Old Testament we have
answered the Jews, by whose question about our not observing the precepts Faustus thought
we would be puzzled. But what answer can you give to the question, why you deceive simple-
minded people by professing to believe in the New Testament, while you not only do not
believe it, but assail it with all your force? It will be more difficult for you to answer this
than it was for us to answer the Jews. We hold all that is written in the Old Testament to
be true, and enjoined by God for suitable times. But in your inability to find a reason for
not receiving what is written in the New Testament, you are obliged, as a last resource, to
376 Book vi. 2.
Faustus insists that the Old Testament promises are radically different from those of the New. Augustin admits a difference, but maintains that the moral precepts are the same in both.
301
Faustus insists that the Old Testament promises are radically different…