But here it is said by some, that the context of the passage under debate (1 Cor. xi. 28..)
plainly limits the meaning of the word in that place; the apostle there speaking of those
things that had appeared among the communicants at Corinth, which were of a scandalous
nature, so doubtless unfitting them for the Lord’s supper, and therefore when the apostle
460
directs them to examine or prove themselves, it is but just, to suppose his meaning to be,
that they should try whether they be not disqualified by scandal.—To this I answer, though
the apostle putting the Corinthians upon trying themselves, was on occasion of mentioning
some scandalous practices found among them, yet this is by no means any argument of its
being only his meaning, that they should try themselves whether they were scandalous persons;
and not, that they should try whether they were genuine Christians. The very nature of
scandal (as was observed before) is, that which tends to obscure the visibility of the piety of
professors, and wound others’ charity towards them, by bringing the reality of their grace
into doubt; and therefore what could be more natural, than for the apostle, when mentioning
such scandals among the Corinthians, to put them upon trying the state of their souls, and
proving their sincerity? This is certainly the case in this apostle’s directing the same persons
to prove themselves, 2 Cor. xiii. 5.. using the same word there which he uses here, and giving
his direction on the like occasion. For in the second epistle (as well as in the first) his putting
them on examining and proving themselves, was on occasion of his mentioning some scandals
found among them; as is plain from the foregoing context. And yet there it is expressly said,
that the thing concerning which he directs them to prove themselves, is, whether they be in
the faith, and whether Christ is in them. Nor is there any thing more in the preceding context
of one place, than in that of the other, obliging or leading us to understand the apostle to
intend only a trying whether they were scandalous, and not whether they were sincere
Christians.
And as to the words following in the next verse; “For he that eateth and drinketh unwor-
thily, eateth and drinketh judgment to himself, not discerning the Lord’s body:”—these
words by no means make it evident, (as some hold,) that what the apostle would have them
examine themselves about, is, whether they have doctrinal knowledge, sufficient to under-
stand, that the bread and wine in the sacrament signify the body and blood of Christ: but
on the contrary, to interpret the apostle in this sense only, is unreasonable, upon several
accounts. (1.) None can so much as attempt such an examination, without first knowing,
that the Lord’s body and blood is signified by these elements. For merely a man putting this
question to himself, Do I understand that this bread and this wine signify the body and blood
of Christ? supposes him already to know it from a previous information; and therefore to
exhort persons to such an examination, would be absurd. And then, (2.) It is incredible, that
there should be any such gross ignorance in a number of the communicants in the Corinthian
church, if we consider what the Scripture informs us concerning that church. St. Paul was
an able and thorough instructor and spiritual father, who founded that church, brought
1819
SECTION IX. Qualifications for the Lord's supper.