Historical Note on the So-Called “Eighth General Council” and Subsequent Councils.
Whatever may be the final verdict of history with regard to the Caroline books, to the
action of this Synod of Frankfort, and to the genuineness of the account of the Convention
of Paris, there can be no doubt with regard to the position held by the Seventh of the Ecu-
menical Synods in all subsequent conciliar action.
In 869555 was held at Constantinople what both the Easterns and Westerns then con-
sidered to be the Eighth of the Ecumenical Synods. Its chief concern was to restore peace
and it thought to accomplish this by taking the strongest position against Photius. At this
Synod the Second Council of Nice was accepted in the most explicit manner, not only its
teaching but also its rank and number.556
587
But not many years afterwards Photius again got the upper hand and another synod
was held, also at Constantinople, in a.d. 879, which restored Photius and which was afterwards
accepted by many Easterns as the Eighth of the Ecumenical Synods. But at this synod, as
well as in that of 869, the position of Second Nice was fully acknowledged. So that after that
date, roughly speaking one century after the meeting of the Seventh Synod, despite all op-
position it was universally recognized and revered, even by those who were so rapidly
drifting further and further apart as were the East and West in the time of Photius and his
successors.
At the Council of Lyons in a.d. 1274 there was consent on all hands that all were united
in accepting the Seven Synods as a basis of union.
And finally when the acts and agreements of the Council of Florence (1438) appeared
in the first edition issued under papal authority, that synod was styled the “Eighth,” and in
this there was no accident, for during the debate the Cardinal Julian Cæsarini had asked the
Greeks for the proceedings of the Eighth Synod and Mark answered: “We cannot be forced
to count that synod as ecumenical, since we do not at all recognize it but in fact reject it.…“A
few years afterwards was held a second synod which restored Photius and annulled the acts
of the preceding assembly, and this synod also bears the title of the Eighth Ecumenical. But
Cardinal Julian did not enter on any defence of the Ecumenical character of this so-called
“Eighth Synod.”557
For the purposes of this discussion, the matter is perfectly clear, and even if some later
writers speak still of the “Six Ecumenical Councils” in doing so they are rejecting the Eighth
as much as the Seventh; in fact they are rejecting neither, but speaking as did St. Gregory,
555 Hefele. Concilien, § 487, also Fleury.
556 The definition of faith says: “also we confess that the Seventh Holy and Ecumenical synod, which met
in Nice for the second time, taught in accordance with orthodoxy, etc.” (Labbe and Cossart, Concilia, Tom.
VIII., col. 1147.)
557 For which Baronius condemns him in his Annales, a.d. 869.
Historical Note on the So-Called “Eighth General Council” and Subsequent Councils.
1079
Historical Note on the So-Called “Eighth General Council” and Subsequent…